Moparts

What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer?

Posted By: badblack68

What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 08:34 PM

What off the shelf brand and viscosity dino oil do you guys prefer. I'm getting ready to change the break in the oil in my fresh stock 440 magnum.
Posted By: RapidRobert

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 08:37 PM

Rotella diesel oil, I thinks its 15-40. Even the reduced zinc formula is still pretty good
Posted By: 70Cuda383

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 08:39 PM

you're about to get 50 replies claiming 50 different brands is best!

I like the rotella stuff too, but at 15w40, I wanted to see if something a little thinner would work for me and save a few HP too, but there's no HD diesel type oil less than a 15w40, so I picked up some royal purple from the local Jegs storefront thats 10w40. haven't run it yet though.
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 08:46 PM

Here's some info from Caldwells speed shop website.
Q:
I use Rotella or other diesel oil in my classic or high performance car. Doesn't this provide the ZDDP protection necessary for my car?


A:
Diesel oil is engineered with a higher amount of dispersant and detergent to deal with the increased amount of soot and other hydrocarbon by products in a diesel engine. This high amunt of detergent can increase the decomposition temperature of the ZDDP reducing its effectiveness as an anti-wear agent. Diesel engines are manufactured with this issue in mind. Gasoline engines are not.

Typically the viscosity range for diesel oil does not include the very low 5w and 10w values. Tighter bearing clearances in passenger automobiles often require free flowing oil, diesel engines typically have larger bearing clearances minimizing the need for free flowing oils.

Diesel oil is not optimized for film strength as needed in high performance and classic automobiles. For a given viscosity high detergent diesel oil has a lower surface tension and lower shear strength which can cause increased bearing wear, especially in high reving engines.

Diesel oil has metallic based detergents which can cause excessive ash deposits (sludge) in your engine. These deposist in worse case scenarios may cause detonation especially in high compression or supercharged applications.

Newer diesel automobiles are being designed with catalyic converters the implication is that ZDDP levels will be reduced in diesel oil making the discussion a moot point as ZDDP is removed diesel oils will become totally unacceptable.
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 09:02 PM

I just don't want to end up getting whipped by that guy with the dipstick...
Posted By: Neil

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 09:06 PM

Valvoline 10-40 with a little GM EOS.

I thought about using a synthetic, but it's too expensive for a daily driver + the guy who machined my rotating assembly said it's not worth the extra money and that a good number of racers still use conventional oils. He's done crankshaft work since the early 70's, in addition to drag racing his cars on the side, so he's pretty much seen it all.
Posted By: 68Bullit

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 09:21 PM

Quote:

so I picked up some royal purple from the local Jegs storefront thats 10w40. haven't run it yet though.




I just put in 5 quarts of Royal Purple for the first time. I think this will be the oil that I'll continue to use for my mild small block. It has the required ppm of zinc/phosphorous, and is the normal 10W-40 for automobiles.



Quote:

I just don't want to end up getting whipped by that guy with the dipstick...




Yeah but remember, you'll still get whipped, even "FOR thinking with your dipstick, Jimmy"
Posted By: DZJim

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 09:26 PM

Quote:

Here's some info from Caldwells speed shop website.
Q:
I use Rotella or other diesel oil in my classic or high performance car. Doesn't this provide the ZDDP protection necessary for my car?


A:
Diesel oil is engineered with a higher amount of dispersant and detergent to deal with the increased amount of soot and other hydrocarbon by products in a diesel engine. This high amunt of detergent can increase the decomposition temperature of the ZDDP reducing its effectiveness as an anti-wear agent. Diesel engines are manufactured with this issue in mind. Gasoline engines are not.

Typically the viscosity range for diesel oil does not include the very low 5w and 10w values. Tighter bearing clearances in passenger automobiles often require free flowing oil, diesel engines typically have larger bearing clearances minimizing the need for free flowing oils.

Diesel oil is not optimized for film strength as needed in high performance and classic automobiles. For a given viscosity high detergent diesel oil has a lower surface tension and lower shear strength which can cause increased bearing wear, especially in high reving engines.

Diesel oil has metallic based detergents which can cause excessive ash deposits (sludge) in your engine. These deposist in worse case scenarios may cause detonation especially in high compression or supercharged applications.

Newer diesel automobiles are being designed with catalyic converters the implication is that ZDDP levels will be reduced in diesel oil making the discussion a moot point as ZDDP is removed diesel oils will become totally unacceptable.




I don't know who writes for Caldwell's speed shop, but when I got to the last sentence I thought: "pretty strong statement..."

So I looked at Shell's Rotella website and find that their single grade Rotella T is available in 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 weight viscosities and is API CF-4, and SJ as well as CF and SH. So I looked at the multi-viscosity 15-40 and its a long list including API SM and SL, and they show information that the wear resisting properties of the new formulation are improved over the older stuff.

Now who 'ya gonna believe? edit: Say, 'ya don't suppose the speed shops sell expensive oil additives and specialty motor oils do 'ya...?
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/18/09 11:43 PM

Quote:

Valvoline 10-40 with a little GM EOS.

I thought about using a synthetic, but it's too expensive for a daily driver + the guy who machined my rotating assembly said it's not worth the extra money and that a good number of racers still use conventional oils. He's done crankshaft work since the early 70's, in addition to drag racing his cars on the side, so he's pretty much seen it all.



Here's what Caldwells says about GM eos:
Q:
What about using GM EOS?


A:
GM EOS contains less than 1/2 the amount of ZDDP as ZDDPLus. The concentration of ZDDP in GM EOS is diluted in a 16 ounce bottle. The proper level of ZDDP for high performance and classic cars is a minimum of 1300 PPM. To do this with GM EOS you would have to use 16-32 ounces of EOS significantly changing the viscosity of your oil and causing possible foaming within the oil.

ZDDPlus is clearly a better choice with one 4 Oz. bottle capable of raising 5 quarts of oil to a level of 1700-1800 PPM.

One 4 ounce bottle of ZDDPlus has the same level of ZDDP as 34.3 ounces of GM EOS.
Posted By: 05dakota

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 02:18 AM

who is Caldwell?
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 02:33 AM

Quote:

who is Caldwell?



www.caldwellsspeedshop.com
Posted By: ahy

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 02:34 AM

Quote:

you're about to get 50 replies claiming 50 different brands is best!

I like the rotella stuff too, but at 15w40, I wanted to see if something a little thinner would work for me and save a few HP too, but there's no HD diesel type oil less than a 15w40, so I picked up some royal purple from the local Jegs storefront thats 10w40. haven't run it yet though.




Shell makes Rotella in 10W-30. Walmart usually stocks it but the parts stores don't.
Posted By: 05dakota

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 02:35 AM

amazing he pushes the product he sells.
Posted By: MNobody

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 04:01 AM

Here's the reply i got from Shell about Rotella...


With the introduction a couple of years ago of ILSAC specification GF-4 and
API specification SM for gasoline-only engine oils, the amount of
phosphorous in the oil had to be reduced to prolong the life of catalytic
converters. Zinc-based anti-wear compounds, which also contain phosphorous,
were reduced as well. These zinc compounds work well to protect flat tappet
engines from excessive wear, so the modern gasoline-only engine oils are not
as effective in this regard as they once were.

Diesel engine oils don't suffer from the same requirements to protect
catalytic converters, so the amount of zinc-based anti-wear additives
remained high. Products like Shell Rotella T Oils, which also carry API
S-series licenses for gasoline engines, have found favor for flat tappet
engines.

There has been a recent change to the API specification required for oils
used in 2007 big rig diesel engines to reduce particulate emissions, API
CJ-4. As a result, the zinc content in Shell Rotella T Multigrade Oils has
been reduced slightly from about 1400 ppm to about 1200 ppm. Even at these
slightly decreased levels, Shell Rotella T Multigrade Oils still have at
least 50% more of these anti-wear additives as most current gasoline-only
engine oils. These levels of zinc have historically offered good protection
in flat tappet applications.

Regards,
Edward Calcote
http://www.shell.com/us/lubricants/



Attached File
Posted By: MNobody

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 04:10 AM

Here's Castrol


Thank you for contacting Castrol,

The latest API SM/ILSAC GF-4 category calls for reduced Zinc and Phosphorus
levels to allow extended catalyst life in current model vehicles. There
appear to be field issues associated with the SM/GF-4 oil's level of
antiwear in the classic car engines known as flat tappet cam engines. The
current late model passenger car engines are not flat tappet cam engines and
have no reported field issues related to the level of antiwear chemistry in
the SM/GF-4 oils.


Product Recommendations for Flat Tappet (Solid Lifter) Cam Engines:
Castrol Syntec 5W-40 (min Zn = 0.10 wt % = 1000 ppm)(full synthetic)
Castrol Syntec 20W-50 (Recent reformulation identified by "Recommended for
Classic Cars" text on back label) (min Zn = 0.12 = 1200 ppm)(full synthetic)
PREFERRED
Castrol TWS Motorsport 10W-60 (BMW dealerships) (min Zn = 0.10 = 1000
ppm)(full synthetic)
BMW Long Life 5W-30 (BMW dealerships)(min Zn = 0.095 = 950 ppm)(full
synthetic)

New Motorcycle Products, Expected to be Available Q2 2008:
Castrol 4T 10W-40 and 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.10 wt % = 1000 ppm)
Castrol Actevo X-Tra 10W-30, 10W-40, 20W-40 and 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.10 = 1000
ppm)
Castrol Actevo X-Tra Offroad 10W-40 and 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.10 = 1000 ppm)
Castrol Power RS GPS 10W-30, 10W-40 and 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.12 = 1200 ppm)
PREFERED
Castrol Power RS R4 10W-50 and 5W-40 (min Zn = 0.12 = 1200 ppm) PREFERED
Castrol Power RS V-Twin 20W-40 and 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.12 = 1200 ppm)
PREFERED

Existing Motorcycle Products, Will Be Transitioning Out:
Castrol Grand Prix 4-Stroke Motorcycle Oil 10W-40, 20W-50 (min Zn = 0.10 wt
% = 1000 ppm)
Castrol GO! 10W-40, 20W-50 Motorcycle Oil (min Zn = 0.10 = 1000 ppm)

Castrol Consumer Relations
Posted By: MNobody

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 04:11 AM

And Kendal


Kendall® GT-1 High Performance Motor Oil is a high-quality
engine oil specially designed for use in gasoline-fueled vehicles
operating under high-temperature or severe driving conditions,
such as towing heavy loads, as well as in competition engines
and high-performance street engines.
GT-1 High Performance Motor Oil is formulated to provide
excellent wear protection, to minimize the formation of sludge
and varnish, and to resist viscosity and thermal breakdown, even
in severe service. It also protects against rust and bearing
corrosion, and has good foam resistance. The SAE 20W-50
viscosity grade is fortified with additional zinc
dialkyldithiophosphate (ZDDP) additive to provide enhanced
wear protection and oxidation resistance for use in the most
demanding applications. It is particularly recommended for use in
turbocharged engines and in high-performance engines with
flat-tappet camshafts, especially during the critical break-in
period.
Applications
• Gasoline-fueled passenger cars, light trucks and sport utility
vehicles that do not require an ILSAC GF-4 oil for warranty
coverage
• Competition engines and high-performance street engines
• Nitromethane-fueled drag racing vehicles (Nitro 70 grade)
• Gasoline engines where monograde engine oil is
recommended
GT-1 High Performance Motor Oil meets or exceeds the
requirements of:
• API Service SM, SL (all grades except SAE 50 & Nitro 70)
Features/Benefits
• Excellent resistance to viscosity and thermal breakdown at
high temperatures
• Protects against sludge and varnish formation
• Excellent wear protection
• Protects against rust and bearing corrosion
• Good foam resistance
• Formulated for engines equipped with turbochargers or
superchargers
• Enhanced wear protection for engines with flat-tappet
camshafts (SAE 20W-50)
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 11:40 AM

So what brand and viscosity dino oil is everyone using in their 440's? There is so much info on the net that it's confusing.
Castrol, pennzoil, valvoline, etc?
Posted By: DennisH

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 12:13 PM

Valvoline 10-40 then Royal Purple after 2500 miles.
Posted By: Lefty

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 04:32 PM

Lubrication Engineers. I run the 15-40 in my 440 and Cummins diesel. I use their other products every where else. Great oil...

http://www.le-inc.com/
Posted By: Lefty

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 04:36 PM

Quote:

Diesel oil has metallic based detergents which can cause excessive ash deposits (sludge) in your engine.




Completely not true! My 440 is spotless inside the valve covers. It's cleaner than when it was reassembled after a rebuild. Show me some proof that diesel oil causes sludge.
Posted By: Neil

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 05:17 PM

Seems like a diesel oil would be loaded with extra detergents to keep sludge away.
Posted By: deansrr

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 06:45 PM

VALVOLINE VR1 10W30 OR 20W50
Posted By: MNobody

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 07:44 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Diesel oil has metallic based detergents which can cause excessive ash deposits (sludge) in your engine.




Completely not true! My 440 is spotless inside the valve covers. It's cleaner than when it was reassembled after a rebuild. Show me some proof that diesel oil causes sludge.





I just adjusted the valve lash on my 318 and everything was spotless, i'm running Rotella 15-40.
Posted By: John_Kunkel

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 07:50 PM

Quote:

Here's some info from Caldwells speed shop website.





Lots of opinion there.
Posted By: hemicop

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 08:27 PM

Bradd Penn when I can find it, otherwise Valvoline.....
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 09:14 PM

Is it true that Carquest branded oil is really Valvoline?
Posted By: badblack68

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 09:18 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Here's some info from Caldwells speed shop website.





Lots of opinion there.



How do you come to the conclusion that what is stated there is opinion? They have charts from the various oil brands and additives that state the facts on those products from test laboratories. I don't believe they're making up those figures just to sell zddp.
Posted By: earlybee

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 10:34 PM

O/T, I just changed the oil in my truck, $4.00 a qt for valvoline at Oreilys!
Posted By: 68Bullit

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/19/09 11:16 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Valvoline 10-40 with a little GM EOS.

I thought about using a synthetic, but it's too expensive for a daily driver + the guy who machined my rotating assembly said it's not worth the extra money and that a good number of racers still use conventional oils. He's done crankshaft work since the early 70's, in addition to drag racing his cars on the side, so he's pretty much seen it all.



Here's what Caldwells says about GM eos:
Q:
What about using GM EOS?


A:
GM EOS contains less than 1/2 the amount of ZDDP as ZDDPLus. The concentration of ZDDP in GM EOS is diluted in a 16 ounce bottle. The proper level of ZDDP for high performance and classic cars is a minimum of 1300 PPM. To do this with GM EOS you would have to use 16-32 ounces of EOS significantly changing the viscosity of your oil and causing possible foaming within the oil.

ZDDPlus is clearly a better choice with one 4 Oz. bottle capable of raising 5 quarts of oil to a level of 1700-1800 PPM.

One 4 ounce bottle of ZDDPlus has the same level of ZDDP as 34.3 ounces of GM EOS.




Yeah but then you gotta watch out for TOO much zinc. The Reps at Royal Purple have advised that anything used regularly that is more than the needed 1100-1300 ppm of zinc/phosp. could cause an ashing or coking effect.

This, again, is why I like just using a good brand of oil such as Royal Purple that has just enough ppm of zinc, and then I don't have to worry about additives, how much zinc they have, etc, etc.....
Posted By: DZJim

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 01:51 AM

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Here's some info from Caldwells speed shop website.





Lots of opinion there.



How do you come to the conclusion that what is stated there is opinion? They have charts from the various oil brands and additives that state the facts on those products from test laboratories. I don't believe they're making up those figures just to sell zddp.




Anybody else followup the link to "caldwellsspeedshop" ? What do they sell? I don't see anything except the oil additive. I clicked on the link at their website supposedly to the independent laboratory testing...HaHa: 404 not found.
Posted By: Chris2581

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 02:50 AM

I use Mobil Delvac 1300 in all of my engines.It's a 15w40 diesel rated oil,and I've had very good results with it.
Posted By: hooziewhatsit

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 04:11 AM

I use Delo 400. $12/gallon. Has 1200ppm zinc, 1300ppm Phosphorus.

https://www.cbest.chevron.com/generated/MSDS/PDS29828888.PDF
Posted By: CompSyn

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 06:41 PM

Quote:

I use Delo 400. $12/gallon. Has 1200ppm zinc, 1300ppm Phosphorus.

https://www.cbest.chevron.com/generated/MSDS/PDS29828888.PDF




That’s great to see that the Delo 400 “Low Emissions” CJ-4 stuff that passes 2007 EPA exhaust particulate emissions standards still has Zinc/Phos. @ 1300ppm/1200ppm as of May 2009.

Also notice the fine print below the specs:

"Typical test data are average values only. Minor variations which do not affect product performance are to be expected in normal manufacturing."

Sure does give them an easy out if they decide to make adjustments to the formula at any time.

CompSyn
Posted By: 7DRRunner

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 07:00 PM

Quote:

Valvoline 10-40 then Royal Purple after 2500 miles.




another RP fan, right here

thats what I have in my 440
Posted By: 67MIke

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/20/09 10:48 PM

15 40 delvac mobil shell or rotella. Used castrol in my mgb for 10 years. very clean, same in the 440. My friend swears by the diesel oil in his jeep 250 k on his straight 6 jeep
Posted By: 1MYTGTX

Re: What brand of dino oil do you guys prefer? - 05/21/09 06:16 PM

Just picked up 7 qts of Valvoline VR1 Racing Oil 20w-50


Even had a little sticker on the bottle touting "High Zinc --great for pushrod engines & flat tappet cams"



Quote:

# Valvoline VR1 Racing Oil 20W50 weight

VR1 Racing Motor Oil's exclusive chemistry is designed to reduce friction and enhance power. It is among the most popular engine lubricants in racing, including CART, stock, and drag. It is recommended for engines burning gasoline and full or partial alcohol fuels for track and street service.

Benefits include:
# Ashless additives and ZDDP provide ultimate wear protection
# Enhanced anti-foam system helps protect the engine even during extreme stress
# Other additives protect against high-temperature deposits for a cleaner engine
# Friction modifiers help improve horsepower output


© 2024 Moparts Forums