Moparts

Broke my K Frame

Posted By: mickm

Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 06:02 AM

So the perch that the engine mount bolts to on the K Frame is completely broken on the passenger side. It has slid about an inch and a half away from it's original position, and it's pretty obvious to see the engine leaning way to the left.

Think this is possible to repair in the car? Lift the engine as far out of the way as possible, weld this thing back on?

Doesn't seem feasible to me, although a friend suggested it.

Pretty bummed out about this at the moment, but I guess as hard as I drive this car, it isn't unexpected.

If I have to take it out, is it reasonable to just hoist the engine out of the way, or do I really need to pull the engine and trans?
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 06:33 AM

Support the engine and pull the k-member out. I have done many k-member repairs, but haven't encountered this issue before. I don't see where it would be that difficult, though. A bare block with the mounts attached should work to get it back. It might also be obvious where it goes...
Posted By: Sixpak

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 06:42 AM

Is it a clean break or has it chewed up the crack some? Can you get it clean enough and prepped in the car to weld in the car? Any issues getting the mig torch head in there and will it be a difficult weld in terms of the position? If it is possible to weld in the car I'd remove any ignition boxes, and voltage regulators or other electronics in the car lest the weld current damage them. I fried a voltage regulator on a mower welding up a part with a mig welder.
Posted By: 71birdJ68

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 07:14 AM

I would say pull it, and send to Mega Parts, I think they have a jig, and then it would be done right. They
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 07:44 AM

Or send it to Firm Feel. While there, they can weld in their reinforcement bracing kit.
Is this the 383 K member or a genuine HEMI K member?
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 09:15 AM

I haven't had a good view of exactly what it looks like yet. It is the 383 K Member, not the hemi one. I think once I have it out it will be very obvious how it all goes back together, I just can't imagine doing a proper job of it while it is still in the car.

I just have to come up with a good way to support the engine, and then the rest is just dropping it out.
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 10:36 AM

That is not a hard to find K member. All 318 and 383 cars used it from 70-72. I am told the 440 cars had that unique skid plate but was otherwise identical.
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 10:37 AM

Like this one.

Attached picture 40 440 K #.jpg
Attached picture 70 440 K.jpg
Posted By: GTSDave

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 02:46 PM

I supported my engine and pulled the K-Member to repair and reinforce at the steering box mounts when I broke a steering box. Made it much easier to repair it, and there was no guessing if I had repaired all the cracks. Included a pic with the k-member out. By the way this was with a low deck, 440-1 heads and the original pro parts headers. Have since gone to a custom set of headers.

-Dave

Attached picture Critter K Member off.jpg
Posted By: CKessel

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 05:51 PM

The 70 unit is unique as it has the sway bar through the k but the steering box angle is the same as the earlier years. 71-2 the box angle changed and to use it you need the center link from those two years too then you should be ok. 71 on is the same as the e-bodies from what I've found out. Found this out when putting a 70 unit in my 65 Coronet.
Posted By: Silver70

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 06:01 PM

Late 69 would have the same indents in the k-frame for the 70 sway bar, just no holes drilled which would be easy to do. I have a 71 k-frame in my 69 belevedere... has no issues with it.
Posted By: cudaman1969

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 10:11 PM

Find another k frame, if the mount is broken, what else?
Posted By: pittsburghracer

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 10:22 PM

Take a good look at your transmission tailshaft while your are under there.
Posted By: HotRod20

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 10:28 PM

I agree with Pittsburghracer.....check your tail shaft while you're under there....great advice!
HR20
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/19/17 11:43 PM

Originally Posted By HotRod20
I agree with Pittsburghracer.....check your tail shaft while you're under there....great advice!
HR20


Ugh..!

Will do...
Posted By: RUNCHARGER

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/20/17 03:04 AM

Good idea: I would expect the left mount to want to pull up, not so much the right one. I wouldn't worry about a new K-member, welding this one shouldn't take more than 30 minutes and you have to pull it out anyway.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/20/17 03:34 AM

Originally Posted By RUNCHARGER
Good idea: I would expect the left mount to want to pull up, not so much the right one. I wouldn't worry about a new K-member, welding this one shouldn't take more than 30 minutes and you have to pull it out anyway.


Yea, my plan is to weld it, and just reinforce all the other welds.
Posted By: 71rm23

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/20/17 05:57 AM

If it can be welded, fine. If needing another K, get a hold of Moparmarks member here. Either way, I'd consider a torque strap for the final install as well.
Posted By: astjp2

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/20/17 10:05 AM

When you pull the kframe, take it to a machine shop and have it hot tanked, less things to burn when welding. Tim
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/21/17 01:57 AM

That is a great idea. I should do that next time.
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/21/17 04:27 AM

Originally Posted By astjp2
When you pull the kframe, take it to a machine shop and have it hot tanked, less things to burn when welding. Tim


That's one of the reasons I have my own hot tank, but I really need to clean it out soon.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/22/17 06:11 AM

Originally Posted By astjp2
When you pull the kframe, take it to a machine shop and have it hot tanked, less things to burn when welding. Tim


Good advice, but won't need to. It was well cleaned out when I put it in, had it powder coated before going in.

Will just have to clean it well for welding.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/22/17 06:13 AM

Got down under the car today, and it is an ugly sight. The outboard side of the perch still looks like it is attached to the k frame, although a little hard to tell. The inboard side is completely separated from the frame, and bent down towards the engine, at least a few inches out of place.

So I'm going to have to bend it back into shape before it can be welded on. I may remove it and add a little structural bracing, just to be sure. Bent metal is bent metal...

I hope to have it out in the next few weeks, but we'll see...
Posted By: Sunroofcuda

Re: Broke my K Frame - 11/23/17 03:23 AM

Originally Posted By mickm
Got down under the car today, and it is an ugly sight. The outboard side of the perch still looks like it is attached to the k frame, although a little hard to tell. The inboard side is completely separated from the frame, and bent down towards the engine, at least a few inches out of place.

So I'm going to have to bend it back into shape before it can be welded on. I may remove it and add a little structural bracing, just to be sure. Bent metal is bent metal...

I hope to have it out in the next few weeks, but we'll see...


Mick, if you need to replace the K-member, you want a good rust-free one. Let me know - I have a few contacts still from TX. & AZ. that should have some good 1970 K-members. From the way you describe it, I would not even bother trying to repair it.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/04/17 04:47 AM

Well, got started this weekend.

Now, you have your high tech way of doing things, and then you have your "whatever is laying around the garage" way of doing things.

I thought about buying a lift thingy that was only $60 shipped, but then I thought that after that it would just be sitting around, taking up space and collecting dust.

So, a few 4x4's, 2x4's and some chain, and here it is!

The perch is completely separated from the k frame. Don't have it out yet, but close. Wow! Busted that thing right off.

On another note, it's been a long time, and I don't have anything specific. How do I get the torsion bars out? And yes, all of the preload is off.

Attached picture IMG_4868.jpg
Posted By: Dave Hall

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/04/17 06:13 AM

You should be able to remove the balloon seal and the clip and slide them back. Might take a little jacking on the lower control arm. Very slight to get it to line up. I changed the torsion bars on my Dart and seems like someone had an oil filter wrench type tool for grabbing the thing and then hammering. Fasten the tool towards the rear X member so you can swing at it. I forget now... Anyone?
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/04/17 06:15 AM

Several ways to get the torsion bars out. One way is to use the control are to push the whole thing out. I have also use two u-bolts to clamp a piece of channel iron so that I had something to hit to knock them out.
Posted By: Pntastar69

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/04/17 02:19 PM

Just removed mine over the weekend. Support the LCA's w/a jack, loosen both LCA pivot nuts, back off the height adjusters, and give the LCA's a whack w/hammer and block of wood rearward. The bars should pop right out.
Posted By: CKessel

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/05/17 04:56 PM

Watch my video on YouTube about t-bar removal. The one by Roll Another One Fabrications.
Posted By: Morty426

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 12:05 AM

Originally Posted By astjp2
When you pull the kframe, take it to a machine shop and have it hot tanked, less things to burn when welding. Tim


Good luck finding a machine shop with a hot tank in California.
Posted By: Morty426

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 12:07 AM

I would highly recommend replacing the whole thing with the proper Hemi K frame
Posted By: 469runner

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 02:33 AM

Originally Posted By Morty426
I would highly recommend replacing the whole thing with the proper Hemi K frame
This. Mega Parts will set you up. It will place the engine perfectly in the engine compartment.
Posted By: 70sixpkrt

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 03:19 AM

Originally Posted By Morty426
I would highly recommend replacing the whole thing with the proper Hemi K frame

iagree
Your Hemi puts out a lot of power. Too much for a 383 K Frame. You don't want to do this a second time.
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 07:36 AM

You guys have a stockpile of these rare 1970 only K members? From what I understand, the 1970 model is unique, the 71-71 fits but the steering box mounts are angled slightly.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 08:24 AM

Originally Posted By Pntastar69
Just removed mine over the weekend. Support the LCA's w/a jack, loosen both LCA pivot nuts, back off the height adjusters, and give the LCA's a whack w/hammer and block of wood rearward. The bars should pop right out.


That worked well for the right side, left side I can't move at all. I've triple checked that all nuts are loose, clip is out at the back, but it just doesn't want to move. I put these bars in about 10 years ago, and the car hasn't seen weather, no rust or anything, but something is keeping that LCA from moving, or the bar from coming out.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 08:26 AM

Originally Posted By CKessel
Watch my video on YouTube about t-bar removal. The one by Roll Another One Fabrications.


I did check this out. I played with moving the adjuster up and down, didn't help, although I didn't work it up and down and find the middle point. I'll try that.
Posted By: CKessel

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 04:44 PM

You need to get the pressure off the hexes of the bar and the sockets, then they should slide out. Factory bars have a bit of a helix/twist in the hex which helps to keep them in. Think of it as a fastener stuck in your socket, after putting some grunt to it, that you have to change the rotation back the other way for it to pop loose. Loosening up the control arm shaft nut, say a little less than 1/4", then thumping it back gets it unstuck from the k and helps it to rotate freely to further aid getting the bars free.
Posted By: Pntastar69

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 04:57 PM

Originally Posted By mickm
Originally Posted By Pntastar69
Just removed mine over the weekend. Support the LCA's w/a jack, loosen both LCA pivot nuts, back off the height adjusters, and give the LCA's a whack w/hammer and block of wood rearward. The bars should pop right out.


That worked well for the right side, left side I can't move at all. I've triple checked that all nuts are loose, clip is out at the back, but it just doesn't want to move. I put these bars in about 10 years ago, and the car hasn't seen weather, no rust or anything, but something is keeping that LCA from moving, or the bar from coming out.


Try jacking up the LCA a bit more. You gotta find the sweet spot where it will slide out.
Posted By: 469runner

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/06/17 05:17 PM

Originally Posted By Frankenduster
You guys have a stockpile of these rare 1970 only K members? From what I understand, the 1970 model is unique, the 71-71 fits but the steering box mounts are angled slightly.
I purchased a 1970 Hemi K-frame from Mega Parts. They take a small or big block frame and cut the mount perches off and weld HEMI perches on. They use a jig so the dimensions are spot on. They are usually made to order so don't let the out of stock keep you from calling in. Sometimes they will require a core to be sent in. http://www.megapartsusa.com/proddetail.asp?prod=MP-HKF103
Posted By: Kern Dog

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/07/17 03:34 AM

Oh, okay. Thank you for the response.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 09:19 PM

Ok, so got it out. I think the pictures below explain it all. I think my repair job will hold up just fine, let me know what you think.


Description: I think this is supposed to be attached.
Attached picture IMG_4876.jpg

Description: Everyone knows black duct tape is superior to the standard silver tape, so I think I got this covered.
Attached picture IMG_4884.jpg

Description: Best part about it, it blends right in, so I don't even have to repaint!
Attached picture IMG_4882.jpg
Posted By: Fat_Mike

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 09:28 PM

Originally Posted By mickm
Ok, so got it out. I think the pictures below explain it all. I think my repair job will hold up just fine, let me know what you think.


Nice job, Mick! Personally, I would have used a generous bead of super glue prior to applying the duct tape. But that might be overkill...
Posted By: krautrock

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 09:29 PM

is there something weird going on with your LCA pivot tube? the weld looks strange.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 10:37 PM

Originally Posted By krautrock
is there something weird going on with your LCA pivot tube? the weld looks strange.


Yes, I noticed that as well. We will be going over the whole k frame, looking for any other issues, so I'll definitely take a closer look at that.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 10:38 PM

Originally Posted By Fat_Mike
Originally Posted By mickm
Ok, so got it out. I think the pictures below explain it all. I think my repair job will hold up just fine, let me know what you think.


Nice job, Mick! Personally, I would have used a generous bead of super glue prior to applying the duct tape. But that might be overkill...


Yeah, I think so. The engine only puts out 700hp, duct tape should handle that! up
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/18/17 10:38 PM

But seriously folks, ee are going to repair it. It is truly amazing, just how bad these welds were from the factory and that it lasted this long. I thought about which way to go, and with the above fact, terrible welds and still it lasting as long as it did, I don't have any doubts that welded properly it will be good from here on out. We are going to go over the rest of the k frame and redo welds that don't look good as well.
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/19/17 04:36 AM

From what I can tell the welder missed most of the mount perch. I picked up an A-body k-member where they forgot to weld in one of the strut rod reinforcement plates. The body of the k-member cracked behind it.
Posted By: RUNCHARGER

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/19/17 05:46 AM

I've seen messed up control arm tubes before, they can be tricky to weld.
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/20/17 05:41 AM

Originally Posted By RUNCHARGER
I've seen messed up control arm tubes before, they can be tricky to weld.


The last few k-members that I have done I have cut the bottom open below the pin tubes and welded from the inside. Might also make sense to open the top and weld it from the top, too.
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/21/17 09:46 PM

Originally Posted By Jim_Lusk
Originally Posted By RUNCHARGER
I've seen messed up control arm tubes before, they can be tricky to weld.


The last few k-members that I have done I have cut the bottom open below the pin tubes and welded from the inside. Might also make sense to open the top and weld it from the top, too.


I'm hoping it doesn't come to that. If so, may be worth just finding another one. I'm hoping to have it back from the powder coating guys, (burning the old stuff off), soon, and then we can really go over it.
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/22/17 05:45 AM

I do it as a preventative measure. I'm not sure about your k-member, but the tubes did not receive much of a weld on one end on A-bodies. Here's a pic. I actually split this K-member so that I could straighten it. In part just to see if I could...

Attached picture DW213185.JPG
Posted By: jbc426

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/22/17 07:23 PM

That car is a beast! Does it already have subframe connectors in it and the front frame rails tied together?
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 12/22/17 08:28 PM

Originally Posted By jbc426
That car is a beast! Does it already have subframe connectors in it and the front frame rails tied together?


I have the US Cartool connectors, the ones that are welded all along the bottom of the floorpan. It makes a big difference!
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/03/18 08:02 AM

So, here is the latest. The K frame is all welded up and ready to go. We tacked the perch on, and then I did a test fit, and it was perfect, so we finished off the welding.

I decided to stick with this (instead of going for a MegaParts hemi K frame, I have the Schumacher mounts), for the following reason. When you look at the photos, you will see how ungodly horrific the welds that held this perch on were. It's absolutely astonishing to me that as bad as these welds were, that the thing lasted this long. The welds along the seams that make the perch itself are very, very nice welds, so no worry at all there. When you compare what was there before, and what is there now, I have full confidence that it will outlive me!

I also put the FirmFeel braces on the LCA's, a few pictures of those.

We also reinforced a number of other areas on the K frame. Some welds I ground away and we redid, and some we just added in places that can only help. Pictures should say everything.


Description: This is where the perch was welded on the top. You can see that the weld barely penetrated the metal of the perch.
Attached picture IMG_4889.jpg

Description: This is along the side. Again, astonishing these held as long as they did.
Attached picture IMG_4890.jpg

Description: A zoomed out shot.
Attached picture IMG_4891.jpg

Description: Control arm with FirmFeel brace.
Attached picture IMG_4904.jpg
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/03/18 08:06 AM

More pics:


Description: The top of the steering box mount. This is from the factory, (minus my cleaning it up).
Attached picture IMG_4910.jpg

Description: Whoops! A split in the metal. Don't know if that has been there, or was caused by the latest incident.
Attached picture IMG_4913.jpg

Description: The perch, with new welds.
Attached picture IMG_4914.jpg
Attached picture IMG_4916.jpg
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/03/18 08:08 AM

And the last few:


Description: A few additional welds.
Attached picture IMG_4918.jpg

Description: The mess on top of the steering box mount cleaned up.
Attached picture IMG_4920.jpg

Description: The split welded up.
Attached picture IMG_4925.jpg
Posted By: VL21

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/03/18 04:52 PM


WOW, some of those factory welds look like my doing!

But, I swear, I was nowhere near the the factory back then, Iowa at the time, in college.

Sooo, my welds WOULD have looked like that ...
Posted By: mickm

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/03/18 06:00 PM

Originally Posted By VL21

WOW, some of those factory welds look like my doing!

But, I swear, I was nowhere near the the factory back then, Iowa at the time, in college.

Sooo, my welds WOULD have looked like that ...


It is scary how bad some of them were. Especially that perch. The guy knew that this was holding the engine in place, but hey, good enough, I guess...

I didn't show any pictures of the before on some of the others, but pretty bad. Hard to believe someone was hired with that lack of a skillset.
Posted By: pittsburghracer

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/04/18 01:30 AM

That looks much better. Great job
Posted By: Jim_Lusk

Re: Broke my K Frame - 01/04/18 01:51 AM

I've seen more sloppy welds on k-members than on about anything else.
© 2024 Moparts Forums