Moparts

Bondo over primer? Will it stay?

Posted By: Saint Crispan

Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 02:36 PM

If you put bondo over primer, will it stay? Or does it have to be strictly stripped metal?

I'm in a bit of a spot because I was spraying primer and put some over a rust hole. The interior of the rust hole I had already treated with Rust Bullet Metal Blast (kind of a "naval jelly" treatment for metal...dilute phosporic acid, essentially). Well, I put some Rustoleum primer over the treated metal, but then I read somewhere that you can't put bondo over anything except bare metal.

So now I plan to cut the edges of the hole around, strip them to metal, but I stil have the interior of the hole, treated and primered...but will the bondo stick?
Posted By: cogen80

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 03:17 PM

i was told to put the bondo over top of epoxy primer when i was messing around with it, not sure about other primers though
Posted By: 05dakota

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 04:15 PM

body filler is not for stuffing in holes
Posted By: Challenger 1

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 05:14 PM

Quote:

body filler is not for stuffing in holes




Posted By: 340dart4spd

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 05:17 PM

Quote:

body filler is not for stuffing in holes




what about Newspaper or rags??lol
Posted By: Exit1965

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 05:37 PM

I've used bondo over rustoleum paint, and have also used it over cheap rattlecan primer, it's still there and doesn't give any indication that it's going anywhere.
Posted By: rjsjea

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 06:26 PM

Quote:

body filler is not for stuffing in holes




Posted By: DAYCLONA

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 07:07 PM

.

Attached picture 4940534-flamer.gif
Posted By: Pacnorthcuda

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 07:28 PM

Quote:

.




You're disturbed Dayclona
Posted By: DAYCLONA

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 07:51 PM

Quote:

Quote:

.




You're disturbed Dayclona







After I read the original post, I just lost it!......it was like the early 80's again, I was going to suggest some waded newspaper, or perhaps doing the repair correctly using and old street sign to fill the hole?....I don't know why he's using spraycans?.....a paint roller works just fine, maybe even blot it on with a paint sponge from HomeDepot.......perhaps you use this technique too?.......hence the need for

Attached picture 4940617-flamer.gif
Posted By: ffej

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 09:58 PM

its best to treat the bare metal with a good epoxy sealer or primer that was made for bare metal before putting the bondo on. is it just a pin hole youre trying to fill? bondo was made to fill inperfections in the surface it wasnt really made to fill holes,jeff
Posted By: 340dart4spd

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 10:52 PM

Quote:

its best to treat the bare metal with a good epoxy sealer or primer that was made for bare metal before putting the bondo on. is it just a pin hole youre trying to fill? bondo was made to fill inperfections in the surface it wasnt really made to fill holes,jeff





I your going to fill pin holes I would use mar-glass before I would bondo... but If it was my car I would cut it out and use a metal patch....
Posted By: Stanton

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 11:02 PM

As previously stated, bondo is not for stuffing in holes. Here's what I'd suggest ....

With some sheet metal screws (wood screws will do in a pinch) secure some sheet metal behind the hole - as mentioned, a street sign does work well.
With a large hammer, pound the repaired area in so that the heads of the screws are below the body line.
Apply a sufficient amount of bondo to level the body panel.
Finish as desired.

Remember, a paint job is only as good as the bodywork underneath.
Posted By: Pacnorthcuda

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 11:10 PM

Quote:

As previously stated, bondo is not for stuffing in holes. Here's what I'd suggest ....

With some sheet metal screws (wood screws will do in a pinch) secure some sheet metal behind the hole - as mentioned, a street sign does work well.
With a large hammer, pound the repaired area in so that the heads of the screws are below the body line.
Apply a sufficient amount of bondo to level the body panel.
Finish as desired.

Remember, a paint job is only as good as the bodywork underneath.




The last line REALLY killed me.
Posted By: 340dart4spd

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 11:22 PM

Quote:

Quote:

As previously stated, bondo is not for stuffing in holes. Here's what I'd suggest ....

With some sheet metal screws (wood screws will do in a pinch) secure some sheet metal behind the hole - as mentioned, a street sign does work well.
With a large hammer, pound the repaired area in so that the heads of the screws are below the body line.
Apply a sufficient amount of bondo to level the body panel.
Finish as desired.

Remember, a paint job is only as good as the bodywork underneath.




The last line REALLY killed me.






Dont forget about wax paper...buddy was a pro...make a good patch for yea
...LOL
Posted By: Pyper70

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/11/09 11:36 PM

I am no body man and I can even tell you ....you dont fill in holes with bondo. If its accessible from behind weld in a plate from behind. If its inaccessible, cut out the bad metal, make a piece out of cardboard and make it fit. Then take the cardboard onto some sheetmetal and cut it as that template. Get some magnets, at least 3, make sure they can hold some weight, tack weld the piece on, grind down the welds. If you are unsure at this point and you arent making a decent restoration, dimple the metal around the seam you just welded and lay down some fiberglass. I dont care for bondo. If you care about the overall straightness of the car with this new piece, start block sanding but it sounds like you are in a rush and trying to keep water out of something....course...thats how I would go about fixing it but I dunno where you are working or on what
Posted By: Darius

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 01:29 AM

What they all said about filling holes with Bondo....
If you are trying to "plug"holes, get a thick piece of copper and hold it behind said hole. Weld will not stick to copper, then weld the hole shut and grind it. Now if there are tiny pin holes in the weld you can fill them with body material like metal fil or bondo.
if it is a LARGE void I would cut a piece of sheetmetal and butt weld a patch in.
I welded all of these side molding clip holes shut using the copper method, worked great. You will have to run the piece of copper under cold water every few holes though.

Attached picture 4941489-IMG_0311.jpg
Posted By: elitecustombody

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 04:02 AM

cut out the rusted area and weld a patch of new metal,grind down the welds and then apply filler,anyone who's using bondo to fill holes should not be working on a car, period
Posted By: DaytonaTurbo

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 04:18 AM

Wow, good job guys. Passing judgement and sentence after one post that doesn't even describe what he's working on.
Posted By: DAYCLONA

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 06:27 AM

Quote:

Wow, good job guys. Passing judgement and sentence after one post that doesn't even describe what he's working on.










That's true........This is Moparts?,....he could have been fixing up a rust hole in his lawn mower?.....tailer?......John Deere?,.....Toyota?.......silly us!, to assume he's working on a mopar!
Posted By: Mr.Yuck

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 01:17 PM

I've always clean the metal down as much as possible before using any filler. I have used filler to hide a few small pin holes but these were on a beater driver. I also have cut out rot and used sheet metal and liquid nails to hold the new metal inplace, the smoothed it over w/ filler. Again not a show car, just a racer that didn't have to look that great. If this is nace car and you want to keeep it, do it right and see a body man.
Posted By: 6PakBee

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 01:42 PM

I'm a big fan of that expanding foam in a can. Just fill in the entire hole with it making sure that you have enough that it expands through the hole. After it hardens, you can sand it and shape it to the contour of the metal around it. A little glaze, a little primer, and it'll be as good as new. As a side benefit, it also provides some insulation in that area of the panel.
Posted By: Mr.Yuck

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 02:38 PM

Quote:

I'm a big fan of that expanding foam in a can. Just fill in the entire hole with it making sure that you have enough that it expands through the hole. After it hardens, you can sand it and shape it to the contour of the metal around it. A little glaze, a little primer, and it'll be as good as new. As a side benefit, it also provides some insulation in that area of the panel.



I had a buddy do that to a 78 -79 volare to get it thru inspection...although he just cut it w/ a big knife and sanded it down flat and spray bombed right over it/
Posted By: DaytonaTurbo

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 03:17 PM

A guy I know used the spray foam on the rotted cab corners of his chevy truck, looked good at first, but that stuff always keeps expanding, especially when it gets hot out. Eventually the "repair" pops.
Posted By: TMP66

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 03:26 PM

Quote:

If you put bondo over primer, will it stay? Or does it have to be strictly stripped metal?





I have never been a filler over any type of primer guy. Just the thought of trapping any uncured solvents under filler stops me right there.
I pulled this from another site. It pretty well confirms my thoughts.

Quote:

"OK--Here's the gospel on body filler/bondo over primer. I used to work as a technical/sales rep for the company that makes rage filler. I know the guys (chemists) that developed the resin for rage filler. I've been a bodyman/painter,sales rep and technical rep for 30 years. The resin in rage and other body fillers is fiberglass (polyester) resin. Today's resin technology makes the adhesion of these new resins as good or better than most epoxy adhesives (glue). They are designed to really stick! Also they are somewhat flexible when used properly. Most or probably all filler manufacturers design and reccommend them to be used over clean and prepped (grinding with course-36 grit) and rust free (sandblasted)and dry (free from moisture) BARE metal. They will stick to epoxy primers with mechanical adhesion-they DO NOT chemically bond with epoxies. If you put filler over epoxy primer it has to be fully cured with no solvents (thinner-reducer) left in the primer and still should be sanded with a course grit and cleaned. In other words- It's a wasted step that may or may not cause adhesion problems later on."


Posted By: 6pkaar

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 04:06 PM

In the recent issue of Mopar Action in an article about secrets of professional body shops it states to never put body filler on bare metal....what gives?
Posted By: ONEBADBIRD

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 04:35 PM

I did not know using bondo was a sin? If the hole is deep enough with enough contours and you think it will stay in there then good. Go with your gut feeling. You treated the metal down in the hole so it should not rust anymore (theoretically). It's your ride do as you wish. My ride may not be perfect to some but I will be the one having some fun. Jay Good luck with your project I know I'll need some.
Posted By: RalleyA12

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 05:46 PM

Quote:

I did not know using bondo was a sin? If the hole is deep enough with enough contours and you think it will stay in there then good. Go with your gut feeling. You treated the metal down in the hole so it should not rust anymore (theoretically). It's your ride do as you wish. My ride may not be perfect to some but I will be the one having some fun. Jay Good luck with your project I know I'll need some.




The trouble is normal body filler is not truly waterproof. Moisture can penetrate it and can cause problems down the road. If you elect to go this route, make sure you use something truly waterproof such as fiberglass matting and resin. Your local autobody store should also have some speciality bodyfillers which are waterproof.
Posted By: Scott Carl

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 07:39 PM

Quote:

I did not know using bondo was a sin? If the hole is deep enough with enough contours and you think it will stay in there then good. Go with your gut feeling. You treated the metal down in the hole so it should not rust anymore (theoretically).



I don't think rust would be the problem. If bondo is simply used to plug a hole of any size, without something for it to hold on to besides the circumfrence of the hole, is not matter of IF it will hold; it will eventually break out. Unless of course you put some newspaper or rags behind it
Posted By: 340SIX

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 07:59 PM

Quote:

I was going to suggest some waded newspaper, or perhaps doing the repair correctly using and old street sign to fill the hole?....I don't know why he's using spraycans?.....a paint roller works just fine, maybe even blot it on with a paint sponge from HomeDepot.......perhaps you use this technique too?.......hence the need for


When the fixed the Levey that broke in new orleans they stuffed the cracks with newspaper at the expantion joints and then spread some sealer on it! Since they were out of what they were supossed to use
Posted By: ONEBADBIRD

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/12/09 09:43 PM

Well I think after everybody's input we have our answer. Some good quality newspaper, A decent sized heavy guage road sign, and some water resistant bondo OH!!! I mean glazing putty. Which gives us a professionally fixed hole no matter what it is? You guys are great. Jay
Posted By: denfireguy

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 05:00 AM

No one suggested lead? The times they are a changing.
Posted By: Saint Crispan

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 05:39 PM

Lot of good suggestions here. I already knew the "right" answer, obviously the best thing to do is to cut out the bad metal and weld in good metal.

But I don't have a welding rig, and I don't see me dropping the $$$ to pick one up anytime soon.

The second best answer was to cut a piece of metal, and solder it in place. My soldering iron is only about 35W, so I don't think I'll be able to do that, either.

This leaves me with the "Liquid Nails" option, which I think is probably how I will proceed. Does it have to be a street sign? Because I think that I can pick up a couple of sheets of heater duct metal and it'd work just as well.

Honorable (dishonorable?) mention goes to the guy who suggested squirting in the expanding insulation...I got a laugh out of it, but I can't see doing that. (Although, to a few elitists I'm sure that my bondo idea is the same thing. Take note: not all of us are professional bodymen, and for some of us, this is the first time we've tried this sort of project.)
Posted By: bonefish

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 05:46 PM

you can use SEAM SEALER to permanantly hold your patch in place,every body guy o know says primer THEN puddy.
Posted By: Mr.Yuck

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 05:52 PM

I used heating duct and the liquid nails for metal on a 68 dart. don't go crazy w/ it and wipe off as much as you can before it sets. It drys HARD and can be a MoFo to sand down...I used a grinder.
Posted By: 4BBodies

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 05:58 PM

Hey, it's your car. I still love my Father to death, even though he still pop rivets his sheet metal work, and goops it with mud. I cringe when I look at it. But, like you, he isn't a bodyman, he has no welder, no training, and his Son couldn't find the time to do it right for him. So I don't judge, and no one here should judge you either.
Posted By: Scott Carl

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 06:53 PM

Saint Crispan,

I had to throw the "newspaper" thing in just cuz somebody already had LOL. No offence intended. Anyway, I know where you are coming from. I'm doing my Challenger on the low buget plan myself and I think what I would do considering the lack of wleding resources is just what you are planning. In addition, I would suggest when you glue your backing in, to try to leave a little gap at the edges of the hole. This would in effect give the bondo a place to squeeze in behind the parent metal and act like a flange for the bondo patch. Also, as it was in deed part of you original question, I share the opinion that bondo sticks best to bare roughed up metal. Hope this helps and good luck on your project

Disclaimer: I'm not a body man; I don't even play one on TV But I've spent 40+ years DYI-ing. You learn what works and what don't after about 39 years YMMV
Posted By: Mr.Yuck

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 07:11 PM

I bought my el-cheapo wire fed unit form Harbor Freight for $179. It works well on small stuff, spot welds, stitch welds, exhaust....
Posted By: 6PakBee

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/13/09 09:39 PM

Quote:

.....Honorable (dishonorable?) mention goes to the guy who suggested squirting in the expanding insulation...I got a laugh out of it, but I can't see doing that. ......




I was hoping someone saw the sarcastic humor in that. I've seen that trick done and it is without a doubt one of the sleaziest moves anyone can do.
Posted By: Saint Crispan

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/26/09 10:25 PM

Thanks for the advice, all. Just for good measure, I decided to take some shots of the holes in question:

Drivers side (shot 1)

Driver's side (shot 2)

Passenger's side (shot 1)

Passenger's side (shot 2)

These I think I can slip a little sheet metal behind.
Posted By: 340dart4spd

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/26/09 10:31 PM

Quote:

Thanks for the advice, all. Just for good measure, I decided to take some shots of the holes in question:

Drivers side (shot 1)

Driver's side (shot 2)

Passenger's side (shot 1)

Passenger's side (shot 2)

These I think I can slip a little sheet metal behind.




weld a patch....imo
Posted By: Neil

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/26/09 10:48 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Thanks for the advice, all. Just for good measure, I decided to take some shots of the holes in question:

Drivers side (shot 1)

Driver's side (shot 2)

Passenger's side (shot 1)

Passenger's side (shot 2)

These I think I can slip a little sheet metal behind.




weld a patch....imo




Weld it up and fix it once and for all.
Posted By: 85_Ram_4speed

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 12:06 AM

With all the critisim here (even though some of it was just for fun) there has to be a memeber of the board that lives near this gentleman to go and weld a quicky patch in for him. I know i would if i lived close.

To the original poster, maybe place an ad on this board in an appropriate section asking for someone to help you weld a patch in. What you have there and the way the proposed fixes would happen, your are probably not going to be happy in the long run with all your time, money and fustration to fix it second rate as opposed to giving someone $40-50 to weld in a couple of patches. Of course this is just my opinion.
Posted By: vancamp

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 12:09 AM

with the pics you've shown you need a cutoff wheel and and least take it by a bodyshop or body college and let someone weld in a patch for you.
Posted By: 340dart4spd

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 12:11 AM

Quote:

With all the critisim here (even though some of it was just for fun) there has to be a memeber of the board that lives near this gentleman to go and weld a quicky patch in for him. I know i would if i lived close.

To the original poster, maybe place an ad on this board in an appropriate section asking for someone to help you weld a patch in. What you have there and the way the proposed fixes would happen, your are probably not going to be happy in the long run with all your time, money and fustration to fix it second rate as opposed to giving someone $40-50 to weld in a couple of patches. Of course this is just my opinion.




bet this guy has a answer
Posted By: AARCONV

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 01:44 AM

fix it right the first time...
but everyone missed the original post...
bondo over primer...go or no go?
Posted By: MOPARMIKE69

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 02:30 PM

Never put bondo over primer, why risk it?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 02:34 PM

depends on what the car is, is it worth the work????
Posted By: elitecustombody

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 02:43 PM

Quote:

fix it right the first time...
but everyone missed the original post...
bondo over primer...go or no go?




every shop has their prefference and there is absolutely nothing wrong with filler over primer or any catalized material,as long as the surface is prepped for it,it has to be sanded very well, just like with anything,I, personally will never wipe filler onto bare metal and have been doing so for 20 years ,haven't had any reason to re-do any of my work ,either it's a 15k paint job or small fender-bender,no problems at all
Posted By: elitecustombody

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 02:46 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Thanks for the advice, all. Just for good measure, I decided to take some shots of the holes in question:

Drivers side (shot 1)

Driver's side (shot 2)

Passenger's side (shot 1)

Passenger's side (shot 2)

These I think I can slip a little sheet metal behind.




weld a patch....imo




Weld it up and fix it once and for all.




Amen!

unless you like ghetto-rigging,I wouln't attempt to use anything but a new patch and a welder
Posted By: Mr.Yuck

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 02:51 PM

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Thanks for the advice, all. Just for good measure, I decided to take some shots of the holes in question:

Drivers side (shot 1)

Driver's side (shot 2)

Passenger's side (shot 1)

Passenger's side (shot 2)

These I think I can slip a little sheet metal behind.




weld a patch....imo




Weld it up and fix it once and for all.




Amen!

unless you like ghetto-rigging,I wouln't attempt to use anything but a new patch and a welder




thems big holes..lol I'd make sure you cut or grind all of that out. Then I'd either weld in a patch or use something like liquid nails to hold it in place. Then you can use a skim coat of filler. I would not start smearing filler over those areas, they need some more work before you start.
Posted By: 69Cuda340S

Re: Bondo over primer? Will it stay? - 01/27/09 08:08 PM

You could buy a mig welder (with gas), read some tutorials on line, ask questions here, practice on some scraps, and then weld a patch in yourself. I took that approach and welded a new spare tire well into the trunk of my car and now the rust is fixed for good. Then when I painted the engine compartment I welded some holes shut and butt welded in a patch by the battery. It takes some time to learn but the average guy can do it.
© 2024 Moparts Forums