Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5
Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144664
11/02/08 12:12 PM
11/02/08 12:12 PM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
NV69B7RR Offline OP
master
NV69B7RR  Offline OP
master

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
From those who ran either one, would you do it again and are you satisfied with the results? I am debating on which one to put into my 69 RR so I'd like to hear about both. My RR has a 512 and a 3:54 Dana if that matters. The thing I didn't like about the Keisler kit is that it isn't centered in the fact 4spd hump (i.e. my carpet kit has to be changed now).
Basically do you gain much of an advantage by using the Keisler kit vs the Passon trans for occaisional daily & highway driving?

Passon or Keisler
single choice
Votes accepted starting: 11/02/08 11:11 AM
You must vote before you can view the results of this poll.
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144665
11/02/08 12:25 PM
11/02/08 12:25 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 36,840
South San Francisco, Californi...
MidPenMopar Offline
Looking for fun? Keep looking
MidPenMopar  Offline
Looking for fun? Keep looking

Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 36,840
South San Francisco, Californi...
A friend had his 883 converted by Passon and he said the work and service was excellent. He was not too happy with the results of the overdrive though as it was not as high a gear as he expected i guess. The Keisler 5-speed would probably be a better choice for long traveling.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144666
11/02/08 12:44 PM
11/02/08 12:44 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
I vote Passon because of three reasons:
1 Customer service before,during,and after the sale.
2 You only have to change a few things for the swap,driveshaft,shifter,bellhousing,speedo cable,etc are all re-used for the Passon conversion.
3 If you ever need a repair part or any type of service work done the Moparts Community is ready to help and your factory service manual is still good.
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144667
11/02/08 12:55 PM
11/02/08 12:55 PM
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
DaytonaTurbo Offline
Too Many Posts
DaytonaTurbo  Offline
Too Many Posts

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
Both have their ups/downs IMO.

Pros to the Passon unit is he's got a great reputation for being one of the good guys in the hobby and he stands behind his products. Plus like mentioned already, it's a stock replacement trans, so you can reuse everything else. Cons to his piece are the o/d gear is only a .80. Now I think he did that to keep the gear spreads reasonable for performance driving, but it does hurt his o/d's usefulness on the highway. However, if you've only got a 3.54 rear, you probably don't need as much of an overdrive ratio as say someone with a 4.10.

Pros to the keisler is their available .64 o/d. That really knocks down the RPMs on the highway, and the extra gear of a 5sp makes it so you don't have to worry about far gear spreads, because the race will be over by the time you are at the end of 4th anyway. Also their trans will have a more modern shift feel to it. Cons is you have to change a lot of components to make their trans work. That trans doesn't shift well if you rev your engine much over 6k rpm from what I've heard. If you do a search you'll see some members who've had problems with this trans, though I think most of them have been since resolved by keisler.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144668
11/02/08 01:06 PM
11/02/08 01:06 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 5,278
San Jose, California
D
DennisH Offline
Vacation
DennisH  Offline
Vacation
D

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 5,278
San Jose, California
There are already plenty of opinions to be found here. 25 thousand + on my Keisler TKO 5-Speed. Overall very good. One back-order part, and a weeping speedo cable both of which were taken care of by Keisler. I would buy it again. Now I can jump in the R/T and loaf along on the freewy the 500 miles to Vegas or Reno no problem. 354's.


Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DennisH ] #144669
11/02/08 01:18 PM
11/02/08 01:18 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
ScottSmith_Harms Offline
Mr Wizzard
ScottSmith_Harms  Offline
Mr Wizzard

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
Having driven several Kielser equipped cars and a couple Passon trans cars, here's my .02.

1. For a true "no hack" install the nod CLEARLY goes to Passon
2. If you drag race you'll like the Passon, the Kielser is not a fast shifting trans, a bit too sluggish and notchy, especially at higher RPMs
3. If you want the strongest trans, Passons will take more HP than a Kielser by a fair margin
4. For cost and ease of install, Passon wins
5. For the best highway crusing O/D situation, Keisler wins due to it's better high gear ratio
6. Fuel milage Kielser also wins, same reason
7. Service - Passon hands down
8. With a 3:54 geared car that you do not want to modify beyond clean/simple easily reversable bolt ons and is mainly street driven and occasionally drag raced - Passon
9. For a modified car that is mainly used for local car shows, street cruising, taken on a good many long highway runs and not much else - Kielser
10. If considering these two companies you should also look into Gear Vendors and Classic 5 Speed before buying, may as well see what everyone is selling before you pull the trigger. I have also driven Gear vendor equipped cars, they should be a consideration for sure, they make a good product.


Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ScottSmith_Harms] #144670
11/02/08 02:00 PM
11/02/08 02:00 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
RTSE4ME Offline
top fuel
RTSE4ME  Offline
top fuel

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
Quote:


9. For a modified car that is mainly used for local car shows, street cruising, taken on a good many long highway runs and not much else - Kielser





I fall under this group and I have a Kielser. I think you find the cost is about the same between the two unless you can just change gear sets.

Also it depends on what type of car you have. B-bodies seem to have the least amount of troubles going to the TKO. I have an e-body and there is no way you can get the trans high enough without modifying the trans tunnel. Which to me...... is no biggie.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: RTSE4ME] #144671
11/02/08 03:21 PM
11/02/08 03:21 PM
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8,094
Sunnyvale, CA
Jeepmon Offline
master
Jeepmon  Offline
master

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 8,094
Sunnyvale, CA
Being an ex-Passon customer.. I cant give a strong enough recommendation, he is a GREAT guy to work with.. Without going into details, I bought an 18 spline Hemi 833-OD, screwed it up and Jamie bailed me out. Keissler would have never done that..

The only advantage I see to Keissler is the extra gear.. Since I race the Duster, it would have been nice to have four true gears and then the 5th as an OD.. With the 833, you have a 3 speed transmission and a OD..

BTW.. the only reason I am an EX-Passon customer is because I swapped to a full race auto 727.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Jeepmon] #144672
11/02/08 05:01 PM
11/02/08 05:01 PM
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
Ludington1 Offline
master
Ludington1  Offline
master

Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
I recently installed the Keisler TKO-600 in my 69 Coronet R/T convertible, which was an automatic.

The kit showed up 100% complete 8 business days from when I called and ordered it, the parts were 100% correct for my application, and both Richard and Gene were really nice to deal with.

I used the hydraulic clutch setup, which requires drilling 3 3/8" holes around the factory hole in the firewall where the stock clutch linkage would go through. I then of course had to cut the hole in the floor for the top of the trans and shifter to come through. I will see if I can get a couple of pics for you.

In the end I don't think the hole was all that drastic, the parts and support were great, and I absolutely love the results. I've got it coming up through my factory AUTO console with just replacement of the top plate to the 4-speed style. The shifting was a little stiff for the first 250 miles, but now is really starting to loosen up and it shifts great.

The complete conversion kit was not cheap, but count me as a very satisfied customer, if you were close to Miami I'd tell you to come and drive my car.

Darren

4788192-Interior-3.JPG (242 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Ludington1] #144673
11/02/08 05:56 PM
11/02/08 05:56 PM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
NV69B7RR Offline OP
master
NV69B7RR  Offline OP
master

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
Thanks for the good replies so far, many good points. I'm leaning towards the Passon just for the simplictity and the ability to use the new parts I already have (clutch, shifter, etc). Theres a lot of open highway between towns here so how the car does at 75mph is important.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144674
11/02/08 08:42 PM
11/02/08 08:42 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
I think I've made my choice clear here on this forum many times.....Keisler,.... the versatility of transmission and reliability, I feel out weigh the other choices out there......if a moderate OD and factory look is what your after?....go with Passon.....but if your looking for modern technology to improve your vehicle, Keisler is the only choice!......Gear Vendors is a "cheap" substitute that pales in comparison to either Keisler or Passon

4788639-0000a.jpg (206 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144675
11/02/08 08:52 PM
11/02/08 08:52 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
ScottSmith_Harms Offline
Mr Wizzard
ScottSmith_Harms  Offline
Mr Wizzard

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
I don't agree on your Gear Vendor comment (and yes, I know when you worked with Pam & Gary you ran a few).
They might cost less than a Kielser but are not "Cheap" (as in low quality) I've driven a few cars with them one of which was 4,000 lb B-body with a blown 900HP Hemi in it running a GV behind a 727, thing ran flawlessly and took ALLOT of abuse with zero reliability issues (dozens of hard lauches on street drag radials) try that with a Kiesler and you'll be picking up the pieces in short order. The GV has it's place, it's not for everyone but they are a quality pieces and should be considered.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144676
11/02/08 09:08 PM
11/02/08 09:08 PM
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild
T
ThermoQuad Offline
top fuel
ThermoQuad  Offline
top fuel
T

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild
How much pain do you like?? If you like a lot of pain get the snake charmers product. If you want your life to be simple and full of smiles as you drive your car down the road get the Passon product.

As far as the mumbo jumbo about the passon gear spread...just more ...
The gear spread on the passon overdrive is Goldilocks...just right!!

And don't forget I haven't a clue what I am doing

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144677
11/02/08 09:18 PM
11/02/08 09:18 PM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
NV69B7RR Offline OP
master
NV69B7RR  Offline OP
master

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
I assume you run the Passon trans in your AAR?
Gear vendors is not an options, I don't care for that set up.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144678
11/02/08 09:24 PM
11/02/08 09:24 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,381
Abilene, Texas
F
fastmark Offline
master
fastmark  Offline
master
F

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,381
Abilene, Texas
I was shifting an 833 when most of you guys were still messing in your diapers so I have been thru a few trannies. I have never had a Passon OD but I have driven an OEM OD and never had a problem with the spread of the gears per say.I drove a Kessler in my buds car and can tell you it shifted about as good as my 93 1 ton with an NV 4500. After all the excuses as to why it won't shift and all the fixes to make it shift, the Kessler cost about $6000 and several months to repair. I have not driven the "fixed" version as of yet but I will let you know how it holds up to a 6500 power shift shortly.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fastmark] #144679
11/02/08 09:31 PM
11/02/08 09:31 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 5,278
San Jose, California
D
DennisH Offline
Vacation
DennisH  Offline
Vacation
D

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 5,278
San Jose, California
I love this thread. I'm not here to sell Keisler. (I did like the Kessler comment, I like Kessler in my Ginger-Ale). Just remember, opinions are like ###holes. Everyone has one. Just like bias.

Do your research and remember buyer beware.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144680
11/02/08 09:37 PM
11/02/08 09:37 PM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 641
Monroe NC
L
Luvcars69 Offline
mopar
Luvcars69  Offline
mopar
L

Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 641
Monroe NC
Put a Passon in & forget about it. I did & I'm 110% happy with it in my 69 Bee with 4:10's. Went from 3200rpm to 2300 SWEET!!! 511 inch & 8 3/4 here. Car looks bone stock with 26" Goodyear PolyGlas tires but boy does it whip the pants off a lot of other Mopar & non Mopar cars!!!LOL
Just ask the guy at Carlisle a few years ago that sells the StageV Hemi conversion heads. smoked him like he was going backwards just east of the Breezewood interchange on the Pa. turnpike. Saw him at the show later & he had the valve covers off of it. I ask what was up & he said he bent some pushrods trying to run a car on the way there. I ask him if it was a Yellow 69 Bee & he said yeah. I laughed & said if he wanted to try on the way home to let me know as I was heading home Sunday at around 4pm. LOL Told him it was a slightly warmed over 383 with a .528 solid lifter cam. He came to the stock 69 B-Body class later & just couldn't get over being beat by a 383. I never did tell him.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144681
11/02/08 10:09 PM
11/02/08 10:09 PM
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
Ludington1 Offline
master
Ludington1  Offline
master

Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
Quote:

And don't forget I haven't a clue what I am doing




I don't know if you have a clue or not, looks like you have a nice looking Plymouth and you made it to track day. Are you famous?

I'd consider myself just knowledgeable enough about my old car to be slightly dangerous when I start any project. I installed my TKO-600 from Keisler over about 3-4 days and it seems to me that it went in and works "as-advertised"... and I'll admit that I haven't a clue what I am doing, with old cars or just about anything for that matter.

Darren

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Luvcars69] #144682
11/02/08 10:14 PM
11/02/08 10:14 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
RTSE4ME Offline
top fuel
RTSE4ME  Offline
top fuel

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
Quote:

Put a Passon in & forget about it. I did & I'm 110% happy with it in my 69 Bee with 4:10's. Went from 3200rpm to 2300 SWEET!!! 511 inch & 8 3/4 here. Car looks bone stock with 26" Goodyear PolyGlas tires




Your math seems a bit off. Should be closer to 2600 rpms???

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: RTSE4ME] #144683
11/03/08 12:22 AM
11/03/08 12:22 AM
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 641
Monroe NC
L
Luvcars69 Offline
mopar
Luvcars69  Offline
mopar
L

Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 641
Monroe NC
Sorry but that's not math that's real world!

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144684
11/03/08 01:21 AM
11/03/08 01:21 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,976
Chilliwack B.C. Canada
R
RUNCHARGER Offline
I Live Here
RUNCHARGER  Offline
I Live Here
R

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 15,976
Chilliwack B.C. Canada
You've got a 512 incher, I would go with the Passon. You should have all kinds of torque to work well with the 4 speed. Smaller engine with less torque would benefit more from the closer ratios of a 5 speed.

Sheldon

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Ludington1] #144685
11/03/08 08:29 AM
11/03/08 08:29 AM
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild
T
ThermoQuad Offline
top fuel
ThermoQuad  Offline
top fuel
T

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild





I don't know if you have a clue or not, looks like you have a nice looking Plymouth and you made it to track day. Are you famous?

I'd consider myself just knowledgeable enough about my old car to be slightly dangerous when I start any project. I installed my TKO-600 from Keisler over about 3-4 days and it seems to me that it went in and works "as-advertised"... and I'll admit that I haven't a clue what I am doing, with old cars or just about anything for that matter.

Darren




Thanks for making my day Darren!!!

I have made it to road course track days many many times in the last 15 yrs with the AAR. I have owned it 28 yrs & it always had a 4 speed. Over the last 7 yrs I have run a Passon 4 speed. Quality goes in before the name goes on!!! 1st a 2.66 1st gear fine spline iron 4 sp for 3 yrs and and now a passon aluminum OD 4 sp. I have thousands of miles on the od unit now and thousands of smiles. I have put almost 100,000 miles on the AAR. The car runs low 12's with ease and hits 130 mph on the road course all day long. Just ask the guy in the WRX what happens....

The reason I commented "I have no clue what i am doing" is because as former snake charmer customer my car and credibility were viciously attacked when i came forward with legitimate engineering issues with the product which made it unsafe at any speed. Rather than be men and admit fault they tried to stick me with the product and that mopar tech guru who used to be a good friend of mine helped them do it. I prevailed eventually or rather the bank prevailed for me. I do know what I am doing as the car will outrun/drive most cars on the road and many on the road course. There are wayyyyyy too many problems still with the snake charmers product for the cost and heaven help you if you have a problem and need immediate parts and or assistance.

Infamous not famous...

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144686
11/03/08 08:52 AM
11/03/08 08:52 AM
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
Ludington1 Offline
master
Ludington1  Offline
master

Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,072
Farmland, IN
Good stuff Tom, glad I could help! Looks and sounds like a nice car, mine is just above beater status and I usually do everything twice... First time to learn how to NOT do it, and the second time I can get pretty close.

I don't have any doubts at all that the Passon trans is great, I can say that adding OD, regardless of what product, has made my car even more fun to drive. In my case the Keisler TKO went in with no problems, I was almost suspicious because I DIDN'T have to do it twice! Hopefully I have continued good luck with it and the Mopar world will have several vendors with constantly improving products to choose from when it comes to OD.

Keep kickin butt on the track, I haven't started chasing WRXs yet but I wasted a Civic hatchback and a diesel Silverado on the turnpike.

Darren

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144687
11/03/08 09:04 AM
11/03/08 09:04 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 74,947
U.S.S.A.
JohnRR Offline
I Win
JohnRR  Offline
I Win

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 74,947
U.S.S.A.
Quote:



Infamous not famous...





Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JohnRR] #144688
11/03/08 11:57 AM
11/03/08 11:57 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 43,512
Round Lake Beach, Illinoisy
Rhinodart Offline
Rhinotruck
Rhinodart  Offline
Rhinotruck

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 43,512
Round Lake Beach, Illinoisy
I cannot comment on the Keisler, but I have driven 5 cars with the Passon and love it! Jamie is indeed a great guy with customer service second to none. The cars I have driven with his trans are a 68 Dart 5.7 Hemi, 2-68 Hemi Darts, one with 720 rear wheel horsepower, a 71 Cuda with a 6.1 Hemi, and a 71 Challenger with a 6.1 Hemi. I have driven plenty of cars with TKO's and enjoy the way they work though. It really depends alot on your skill level also, the Passon is truely a bolt-in if you already have a 4-speed, and uses all factory components if you don't.


The funny thing about science is that if you change one miniscule parameter you change the entire outcome to the way you want it.

JB Rhinehart, Realist

A-Body's RULE!
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144689
11/04/08 09:37 AM
11/04/08 09:37 AM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Tom:
I cannot speak as to what you encountered back when you attemtped to use a Keisler 5 speed kit, I wasn't here. Obviously you had some issues and it didn't turn out well. On behalf of us, I apologise.

Things here are alot different these days as compared to what they were back when you tried the install.

Since I started working here back in Jan. 2005, I am customer service/tech support and I have worked really hard to make us 100% customer service oriented. I bend over backwards everyday to help our customers and even those of you not our customers but still looking for tech help. I have given out my personal phone number for customers to call me at nights and on weekends when they need help the most. It is a never ending process here as we grow and learn from mistakes in the past.

The bottom line is an overdrive will transform the car. Jamie Passon is a great option for those of you whose gearing is more suited to the ratios in his transmissions. He definitely makes a great product and it is based on the A833 so the install should be a slam dunk. He is definitely a knowledgeable, positive force in the Mopar world.

The TKO kit will offer a little more overdrive and a little different gearing set. For some, the gearing is not a perfect fit for their needs, for others, it is a perfect way to go. Yes, the TKO swap will require some modification. We all know the TKO box is bigger in size than a A833. There's just no way around it. In most cases, the E-body cars(4 speed) don't have to cut anything and the TKO will fit in there perfectly. The A body cars will definitely have to modify the floor tunnel. The 4 speed B body guys ('66-'70) will only have to relocate the shifter opening in the floor for the TKO tower to come up thru it. Our shifter adapter piece will still allow the shifter handle to come up thru the orginal console where it was designed to be. All other Mopars, will require some modification in order to get a TKO up in the tunnel.

Let's face it, Mopars were not designed to have a TKO but Keisler has made it possible. The main thing to remember is a 5 speed overdrive will transform the car and allow you to cruise in it like it was meant to be.




Richard
Tech Support

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: rj8806] #144690
11/05/08 08:39 AM
11/05/08 08:39 AM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
NV69B7RR Offline OP
master
NV69B7RR  Offline OP
master

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
Thank you for all the replies. All of you have some good points. I think I'll be going with the Passon OD because of being able to use (new) pre existing parts, and the stock shifter location (as I don't have a console to hide it). I will probably put a Keisler in my 72 Demon eventually.
Thanks again.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144691
11/07/08 09:28 PM
11/07/08 09:28 PM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
First,
Let me say that I appreciate EVERYONE'S input. We are a firm believer that people should make an "EDUCATED" decision. Even if it is not our product. Money comes too hard these days. As for the statement that our transmission and the Keisler tremec kit costs about the same, I think I may have to disagree with you there. I have not spoken to ANYONE to date that has put a Tremec from Keisler in their car for less than $3800.00. Lets not talk about the "base kit." This does not matter what the base kit costs. What matters is the end cost. PERIOD. "How much are you going to have in the car when you put it in first gear and it moves."

We made the final drive .80:1 for a reason. STRENGTH. In order to get a deeper overdrive, the mainshaft gear would have needed to be smaller. This would have significantly weakened the unit. The way I looked at it was... Why put out another transmission that has a deeper overdrive, but can't handle the power? We were concerned with maintaining SUPERIOR strength in this unit. I feel that we have achieved that. As for too wide of a gear spread, one of our test cars is my '72 Barracuda. It is a BONE stock small block car. 340, stock manifolds, 2 1/4 inch exhaust, theroquad. It has F70-14 polyglas tires on it. The car is by no means a powerhouse. It will smoke the tires, all the way trhough first, second and into third with this unit in it. NOW, if the gear spread was too wide, I am fairly confident that it would show up in this car due to its lack of power. But, whatever the case. As for final drive. Keep one thing in mind. More overdrive is not always better for gas mileage. If you are lumbering along on the highway at 2000 rpm on the transition circuit of your carburetor, you are surely going to get worse mileage. So, choose carefully. If you have a 4.10 rear in your car. It drops it down to a 3.28 with our unit. If anyone needs any info, let me know.
Thanks,
Jamie


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144692
11/07/08 10:20 PM
11/07/08 10:20 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,402
Wichita,KS
B
Blakcharger440 Offline
top fuel
Blakcharger440  Offline
top fuel
B

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,402
Wichita,KS
Quote:

First,
Let me say that I appreciate EVERYONE'S input. We are a firm believer that people should make an "EDUCATED" decision. Even if it is not our product. Money comes too hard these days. As for the statement that our transmission and the Keisler tremec kit costs about the same, I think I may have to disagree with you there. I have not spoken to ANYONE to date that has put a Tremec from Keisler in their car for less than $3800.00. Lets not talk about the "base kit." This does not matter what the base kit costs. What matters is the end cost. PERIOD. "How much are you going to have in the car when you put it in first gear and it moves."

We made the final drive .80:1 for a reason. STRENGTH. In order to get a deeper overdrive, the mainshaft gear would have needed to be smaller. This would have significantly weakened the unit. The way I looked at it was... Why put out another transmission that has a deeper overdrive, but can't handle the power? We were concerned with maintaining SUPERIOR strength in this unit. I feel that we have achieved that. As for too wide of a gear spread, one of our test cars is my '72 Barracuda. It is a BONE stock small block car. 340, stock manifolds, 2 1/4 inch exhaust, theroquad. It has F70-14 polyglas tires on it. The car is by no means a powerhouse. It will smoke the tires, all the way trhough first, second and into third with this unit in it. NOW, if the gear spread was too wide, I am fairly confident that it would show up in this car due to its lack of power. But, whatever the case. As for final drive. Keep one thing in mind. More overdrive is not always better for gas mileage. If you are lumbering along on the highway at 2000 rpm on the transition circuit of your carburetor, you are surely going to get worse mileage. So, choose carefully. If you have a 4.10 rear in your car. It drops it down to a 3.28 with our unit. If anyone needs any info, let me know.
Thanks,
Jamie




For some reason I cant find the 833 Hemi OD unit on your website. I would like to know how much one of these units cost and if you also sell it as a gear set only deal if someone wanted to go that route. Thanks.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Blakcharger440] #144693
11/07/08 10:23 PM
11/07/08 10:23 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
Look at the swap meet section of this website under transmissions for sale
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144694
11/07/08 11:52 PM
11/07/08 11:52 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
RTSE4ME Offline
top fuel
RTSE4ME  Offline
top fuel

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,041
MD
Quote:

First,
Let me say that I appreciate EVERYONE'S input. We are a firm believer that people should make an "EDUCATED" decision. Even if it is not our product. Money comes too hard these days. As for the statement that our transmission and the Keisler tremec kit costs about the same, I think I may have to disagree with you there. I have not spoken to ANYONE to date that has put a Tremec from Keisler in their car for less than $3800.00. Lets not talk about the "base kit." This does not matter what the base kit costs. What matters is the end cost. PERIOD. "How much are you going to have in the car when you put it in first gear and it moves."




I put the Keisler kit in for $3450. The only additional items purchased was a disc and T/O bearing. If you really want an apples to apples comparison the costs you would need to compare are the cost of the Passon aluminum case 4sp with the Keisler kit.

In the end I don't think cost is the real factor in deciding between the 2. A few hundred either way is not going to make a difference to me when spending over 3 grand on a trans. I think the fitment issues and intended use is more critical in making a decision.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144695
11/08/08 12:05 AM
11/08/08 12:05 AM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 797
WA
P
pro451bee Offline
super stock
pro451bee  Offline
super stock
P

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 797
WA
Having used a Passon aluminum A833 and now a Tremec , If you have the money go for the 5 speed .Nicer shifting and no leaks , some minor cutting and she fits nicely .As far as strenth , my 451 hasnt chewed up the mainshaft yet . The Passon lasted about 2500 miles .

4799632--3.JPG (130 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: RTSE4ME] #144696
11/09/08 10:17 PM
11/09/08 10:17 PM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
I disagee with the comparison of apples to apples being our aluminum unit to the Tremec. Have you checked the weight? Our CAST IRON trans weighs 120 lbs. The Tremec in ALUMINUM weighs like 118 lbs if I am not mistaken. Our ALUMINUM unit weighs 85 lbs. SO, if you want to compare aluminum to aluminum, we are WAY lighter than the Tremec.


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: pro451bee] #144697
11/09/08 10:22 PM
11/09/08 10:22 PM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
Randall,
Apparently according to your post, you had a mainshaft issue with our trans? I do not recall being contacted by you? Please confirm whether you tried to contact us. It seems awfully wierd that we could not have repaired the unit for you if there was a problem.
Jamie


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144698
11/09/08 11:31 PM
11/09/08 11:31 PM
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 797
WA
P
pro451bee Offline
super stock
pro451bee  Offline
super stock
P

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 797
WA
Didnt contact you .I fixed it and sold it .Wanted a 5speed. Tremec weighs 95 lbs ,and the aluminum bell puts it well under alu A833 and iron bell .

Last edited by pro451bee; 11/09/08 11:36 PM.
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144699
11/10/08 12:50 PM
11/10/08 12:50 PM
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Keisler Sales Offline
Keisler Sales  Offline

Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Quote:

I disagee with the comparison of apples to apples being our aluminum unit to the Tremec. Have you checked the weight? Our CAST IRON trans weighs 120 lbs. The Tremec in ALUMINUM weighs like 118 lbs if I am not mistaken. Our ALUMINUM unit weighs 85 lbs. SO, if you want to compare aluminum to aluminum, we are WAY lighter than the Tremec.




Well I see we have a busy thread coming back from Sema had a great show and a good time.

Actually for your information the TKO with shifter only weighs 99 lbs.

I also want to note that I have done some comparison and quotes. I actually had a couple of customers that received quotes from you to do a auto to manual conversion and you were more money.

The biggest difference is the gear ratios and spacing of the gears.

Scott,

As far as the comment about strength I don't think there is a real difference.

Shifting the TKO is not sluggish. I am going to consider the source of that comment. There is a bit of a learning curve some of us haven't mastered when it comes to shifting a trans.

It's funny to me when you drove a couple of Matt Delany's cars with our product on Power tour and were selling our product a couple of years ago you were nothing but complimentary.


The TKO shifters have at the base at the most 1/4 to 1/2 throw which equates to about 3 to 4.5 inches depending on what handle you have. The shifters are positive and smooth. The trans does have a rpm shift limit typically around 6k rpm.


Keisler Engineering www.keislerauto.com
#1 Choice of Overdrive Transmissions with Over 14,000 Sold
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144700
11/10/08 02:25 PM
11/10/08 02:25 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
ScottSmith_Harms Offline
Mr Wizzard
ScottSmith_Harms  Offline
Mr Wizzard

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 42,714
Spokane Washington
Quote:

Scott,

As far as the comment about strength I don't think there is a real difference.

Shifting the TKO is not sluggish. I am going to consider the source of that comment. There is a bit of a learning curve some of us haven't mastered when it comes to shifting a trans.

It's funny to me when you drove a couple of Matt Delany's cars with our product on Power tour and were selling our product a couple of years ago you were nothing but complimentary.




Gene,

I think my comments were nothing but honest & fair, I didn't bash anyone, just compared based on my personal experience. I gave nothing but my (unbiased) opinions after driving the various transmission combos mentioned in my post.

Matt's were not the only cars I've driven with Kiesler installs, and I understand that at least one of those installs needed some adjustments in order for it to shift better, I gave those a "pass" based on that. Also, concerning my experience as a "shifter", I had plenty after spending several days driving those cars on the power Tour, it wasn't like a simple spin around the block. That being said, I noticed the same shifting experience with other Kiesler equipped cars which were well sorted combos, not to mention that nearly every car I've owned and driven for the past 30 years (drag and street use) were stick cars, I'd say I'm as good or better than most at rowing a manual trans car. Bottom line is that I have PLENTY of shifting experience, they simply don't shift as fast as an 833 IMO. My durability comparsions were based on the limits you guys suggest compared with the limits of an 833 which I've experienced.

And yes, although I have sold (a grand total of 2) of your units in the past, I do not currently sell yours or anyone else's products. I will be kind and skip the reasons why on this forum, but if you think back you'll probably be able to figure that out as you were my primary sales contact. Feel free to give me a call if you want to discuss any of this.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144701
11/10/08 06:59 PM
11/10/08 06:59 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
Gene I will go on record as never installing one of your units,but to compare an internal rail type of shifter to an external Hurst or Long shifter is apples to oranges.You will never be able to shift an internal shifter as fast as an external shifter.
It will always be more "slugish" than an 833 transmission.
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144702
11/10/08 07:32 PM
11/10/08 07:32 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Wheres the Whaaaaambulance when you need it! .....The Keisler vs who or whatever threads will go on forever here, and on other forums, Chevy Ford or Mopar.........regarding this thread, if you want your car to look original, go Passon, you don't like 5, or 6 gears, go Passon, you want to reuse your original componets, go Passon........simple



However, you want a smoother shifting gear box,....run a Keisler, you want to run some really tall gears, and not be restricted to the streets,....run a Keisler, you want to see some phenomenal gas mileage....run a Keisler......as far as reliability, anything will break if abused, be it Factory, Keisler, Passon. Doug Nash, Lenco, CRT,...etc,etc

All I know is, I've been dealing with Keisler for about a decade now,....and yet to have any issuse regarding service,parts, products, etc......any customer's car (smblks to HEMI's) that I've either assisted or completely installed a Keisler transmission into,....usually repeats the prior customers comment...."I'll never go back to a 4 spd".....my sentiments exactly,....I personally would never contemplate a Chrysler 4 spd ever again.....I started driving nothing but Chryslers 30+ yrs ago, (and still do) manuals and autos 64's-on up......but after a drive, about a decade ago in a Keisler equipped car,....there's been nothing in my opinion to equal it.........

And no I don't work for Keisler, or get free "stuff", .......I just support Shafi, Gene, Richard,...and the team that builds and supports a great product!

4804772-0000a.jpg (105 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144703
11/10/08 07:50 PM
11/10/08 07:50 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

Gene I will go on record as never installing one of your units,but to compare an internal rail type of shifter to an external Hurst or Long shifter is apples to oranges.You will never be able to shift an internal shifter as fast as an external shifter.
It will always be more "slugish" than an 833 transmission.
Gus







I'd have to disagree with ya Gus,....I have a Keisler TKO .64OD 5 spd in my Tona' with a 70 B body pistol grip shifter, the throws with the Keisler, even with the 70 B body console pistol grip are akin to the throws in the shorty E body pistol grip,..... shifting an original 4spd 70 B body pistol grip is like rowing a boat!


I have had the opertunity to equip a lot of different Mopars with Keislers, the throw distance is remarkably less with the Keisler,......And once a driver has "broken" his old habits of trying to slam the shifter into gear, he/she soon learns how much faster they can shift,......trust me!, I can shift a Keisler faster than I could any of my other 4 spd equipped Mopars........it takes more than a few days to break you old habits,....esp 3rd gear!

4804826-0609day5.jpg (126 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144704
11/10/08 08:11 PM
11/10/08 08:11 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
But have you ever driven a Pro-shift 833 with a Long V-gate shifter at full throttle???
I have been racing manual transmissions for a while and the #1 complaint of Tremec racers is the shifting effort.Guys with Cobra and Viper transmissions all miss gears because of the internal rail design.Now correct me if I am wrong but aren't these essentially the same basic trans as the Keisler trans???
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144705
11/10/08 08:34 PM
11/10/08 08:34 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Gus......everybody wants to be, or thinks they're Ronnie Sox,.......one problem racing the Tremec on the track or street, is losing your concentration, and going back to old school grab and slam shifting, just can't do that with a Tremec,.....3rd gear, if forced, just locks you out,....akin to missing a shift on a 4spd, regardless of the shifter,......comes down to driver skill, and hand dexterity, as well as RPM, traction, etc.......I'm sure ol' Ronnie missed a few too!

4804959-0000a.jpg (77 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144706
11/10/08 11:17 PM
11/10/08 11:17 PM
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
DaytonaTurbo Offline
Too Many Posts
DaytonaTurbo  Offline
Too Many Posts

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
Agreed. If you're used to - and like the old style transmissions you can just ram into gear, you won't like how a newer trans shifts. They don't want or need to be rammed hard to shift quickly. Instead of a good old fashioned yank, they're more of a simple click. Doesn't feel at home in a muscle car at first.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DaytonaTurbo] #144707
11/11/08 08:23 AM
11/11/08 08:23 AM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
NV69B7RR Offline OP
master
NV69B7RR  Offline OP
master

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 6,005
Reno, Nevada
I'd really like to thank both Jamie and SHaffi for providing input into this thread. That says a lot about both of them and their products they sell. I really do appreciate hearing their opinions as well. Its nice to know they care about the products they sell.
THANK YOU!

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144708
11/11/08 08:41 AM
11/11/08 08:41 AM

A
Anonymous
Unregistered
Anonymous
Unregistered
A



what good is a transmisssion that cant be shifted over 6000rpm???

oh, its good for a show car. thats driven easily.

i want a muscle car that is driven hard. Cant run a 4 sp with steep gears on the street? Why is that?

I run 4.30's in my STREET DRIVEN cuda. 3000 rpm at 55 mph, or 3200 rpms at 60 mph is no big feet for me. thats right where my converter is solid.

if I calculate the cost saving from mileage going from 3200 rpm at 60 mph (9.5 mpg) to 2300 rpm at 70 mph (11.0 mpg if im lucky), I'd need to drive about 150,000 before I make up the cost of a $5000 overdrive system.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144709
11/11/08 09:05 AM
11/11/08 09:05 AM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Quote:

Gus......everybody wants to be, or thinks they're Ronnie Sox,.......one problem racing the Tremec on the track or street, is losing your concentration, and going back to old school grab and slam shifting, just can't do that with a Tremec,.....3rd gear, if forced, just locks you out,....akin to missing a shift on a 4spd, regardless of the shifter,......comes down to driver skill, and hand dexterity, as well as RPM, traction, etc.......I'm sure ol' Ronnie missed a few too!





....that sums up the most frequent call I receive. " I can't slam 2nd to 3rd". After I get done explaining to them that the gates are so close together on a TKO that if you go and "hunt" for 3rd, you'll miss it every time. The key to shifting 2nd to 3rd on a TKO, be it a stock in the box, unmodified unit, or a Keisler modified one, is simply pushing the shifter handle straight forward out of 2nd and it will find 3rd all on it's own. I never get a follow up call from people who tried my method and still can't hit 2nd to 3rd.


Let's face it, the gates on an external linkage 4 speed (muncie, A833 or toploader) are further apart and "require" you to go up, over and up again to hit 3rd. Try that method on a TKO and you'll be cussing alot.

Heck, my daily driver mustang (2000 GT) with it's T45, can't shift like the old school 4 speed pattern. I have to shift it the same way a TKO shifts, or I miss 3rd in it as well.
Once you get accustomed to shifting it, the TKO is extremely fast and reliable.



Richard
Tech Support

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144710
11/11/08 11:06 AM
11/11/08 11:06 AM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass

i want a muscle car that is driven hard. Cant run a 4 sp with steep gears on the street? Why is that?

I run 4.30's in my STREET DRIVEN cuda. 3000 rpm at 55 mph, or 3200 rpms at 60 mph is no big feet for me. thats right where my converter is solid.

if I calculate the cost saving from mileage going from 3200 rpm at 60 mph (9.5 mpg) to 2300 rpm at 70 mph (11.0 mpg if im lucky), I'd need to drive about 150,000 before I make up the cost of a $5000 overdrive system.






I didn't say you couldn't drive a car with steep gears on the street,.....I said your limited to the street!........


How'd you think your 4:30 gear cuda's motor would, if it COULD?, hold together at a 140 MPH!.......I'm running 4:10's in my dana, in my Tona' with a Keisler TKO 600/650, .64 OD.......I can turn 140 MPH with 4:10's.......could you do that?


Gas mileage?.......hows a maximum of 22 MPG with a 450 HP 440/6.....consistently



If you have to "ring" out your car at 6K plus to get it moving .........I think taking advantage of gearing, means less wear and tear on an engine,........And if you think 5th gear is useless on the track.......trust me, I've used it many times

If you enjoy your 4 spd,.....good for you, different strokes for different fokes

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144711
11/11/08 11:50 AM
11/11/08 11:50 AM

A
Anonymous
Unregistered
Anonymous
Unregistered
A



whats your mileage without using the overdrive?

You claim 22mpg??? i find that very hard to believe. not at 70. not at 55mph. maybe at 30 mph. even with your aerodynamic nose.

At .64 od, that 4.10 looks like a 2.62 gear. there was never a 440 6 pack Ive ever seen that got close to that mileage with a 2.76. Maybe 15 mpg at best with a light foot and tiny tiny cam. so you'd have to drive it like a baby even with your mileage master cam

factory cars with 3.23 got 13mpg at best.

Stick some meat under those lobes and your down around 10 mpg.

as for running 140, you run your car on a roundy round track. So besides you, there are probably 3 other guys on here that do that for speed. the rest of them want the overdrive for mileage or for cruising on the freeway.

What I am saying is that the milage difference from turning 3600 rpm to 2300 on the freeway is probably, at the most, 5 mpg. most of these cars get 2500 miles a year MAX due to insurance. and even then, most of that mileage is playing the streets. I wouldnt see any benefit in an od. Im not a power tour guy.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144712
11/11/08 01:56 PM
11/11/08 01:56 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

whats your mileage without using the overdrive?

You claim 22mpg??? i find that very hard to believe. not at 70. not at 55mph. maybe at 30 mph. even with your aerodynamic nose.

At .64 od, that 4.10 looks like a 2.62 gear. there was never a 440 6 pack Ive ever seen that got close to that mileage with a 2.76. Maybe 15 mpg at best with a light foot and tiny tiny cam. so you'd have to drive it like a baby even with your mileage master cam

factory cars with 3.23 got 13mpg at best.

Stick some meat under those lobes and your down around 10 mpg.

as for running 140, you run your car on a roundy round track. So besides you, there are probably 3 other guys on here that do that for speed. the rest of them want the overdrive for mileage or for cruising on the freeway.

What I am saying is that the milage difference from turning 3600 rpm to 2300 on the freeway is probably, at the most, 5 mpg. most of these cars get 2500 miles a year MAX due to insurance. and even then, most of that mileage is playing the streets. I wouldnt see any benefit in an od. Im not a power tour guy.







Dan I have avg 22 MPG recently on a trip from Mass to Georgia (3400 miles roundtrip).....crusing at 70-75 mph,(2000-2200 RPM)....21 hrs straight thru, only stopping for gas, didn't even shut the car off, until I got to my hotel......next day did a few laps around Road Atlanta speedway........total gas cost, round trip was around $450 bucks,.....and gas avg anywhere from $2.50 to $3.50 depending on the state,........I was watching my MPG use, at every fill up, recording my MPG.....22MPG was my avg


If I want to play, I can suck it down to 10 MPG if I have the end carbs open all day!



And as far as your comment that I run "roundy round" tracks, and most guys only want the OD for cruising and highway............I enjoy triple digit speeds on the highway, just as much on a track

for Camming, I run a Crane 470/471 @ 285 duration with anti pump up lifters, and Crane 1.6 rockers....so there's some "beef" there!


Dan,........like I said earlier, if your happy with "old school" thats cool, that's your "bag".....I use to be the same way, I recall when Keisler came out with the Mopar/Tremec swap in the late 90's, and expounded all the virtues of it,....I can recall saying no way I'd do that to any of my cars,........well ... after having done it, A Keisler is now the first thing on the list...I still have my "old school" Challenger T/A 340/6, 4spd 3:91...255/60/15's.......on the street it's a blast to drive, on the highway 60 mph is 3800-4000 RPM!......I hate to take it anywhere because driving long distance just drains you!........A Keisler TKO .64OD is slated for that one when I repaint the car

All I can say is the TKO 5spd lets me enjoy steep gears on the streets, and lets me enjoy knowing I can take the car 1000, 3000 or 4000 miles with out having to change a rear gear set out, or trailering the car......I don't build show poodles or show queens, although I do like my cars to look good!....I build cars to race on the street and track, cruise and enjoy as well......when you have to trailer, or leave a car home because its undrivable,.....thats no fun.........and as far as trying to justify the cost of a Keisler....Why?.....it's just like any other mod,...why put a Hemi in a car, when a /6 gets you from A to B just as well?......You put a Keisler, or anybody elses OD, be it Passon, GV, TKO, etc, etc.......for one thing, a performance aspect, be it the benefits of OD, mileage, reduced wear, or pure driving enjoyment......basically having your cake and eating it too


Another example of the Keisler versitality is several of the G-series (71 wingcars) that I built with the Beinkes (Gary and Pam)......the white 71 Tona' runs a 472 HEMI with one of my custom cast aluminum HEMI sixpack manifolds,....Keisler .64 OD TKO 5spd w/ dana 4:10's.......the car, on it first trip to Carlisle made 18 MPG AVG!(75-80 MPH avg cruising speed))........The orange 71 HEMI Superbird sports one of my HEMI 6 pak inductions as well, runs a .64 Keisler OD,...dana 3:54....dynoed out at 520 HP......avg 16 MPG on the 06 Power Tour( avg cruising speed 90-100 MPH).....and is fully capable of pegging the 150 speedo................Dan I'm not trying to "sell" you on anything here, just expounding the benefits that can be reaped, if you desire?

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144713
11/11/08 01:56 PM
11/11/08 01:56 PM
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,124
Hunt Valley, Maryland
1fastrunner Offline
top fuel
1fastrunner  Offline
top fuel

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,124
Hunt Valley, Maryland
My 440 RoadRunner gets 14 mpg w/ 3:23 gears and a factory 4-speed. I used to get over 15 when my motor was running better. I'm planning on getting somewhere close to 20 after my rebuild and whatever OD I end up with.
Jim

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144714
11/11/08 03:48 PM
11/11/08 03:48 PM
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,912
The Dark Side
Fasbird Offline
master
Fasbird  Offline
master

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,912
The Dark Side
Quote:

whats your mileage without using the overdrive?

You claim 22mpg??? i find that very hard to believe. not at 70. not at 55mph. maybe at 30 mph. even with your aerodynamic nose.

At .64 od, that 4.10 looks like a 2.62 gear. there was never a 440 6 pack Ive ever seen that got close to that mileage with a 2.76. Maybe 15 mpg at best with a light foot and tiny tiny cam. so you'd have to drive it like a baby even with your mileage master cam

factory cars with 3.23 got 13mpg at best.

Stick some meat under those lobes and your down around 10 mpg.

as for running 140, you run your car on a roundy round track. So besides you, there are probably 3 other guys on here that do that for speed. the rest of them want the overdrive for mileage or for cruising on the freeway.

What I am saying is that the milage difference from turning 3600 rpm to 2300 on the freeway is probably, at the most, 5 mpg. most of these cars get 2500 miles a year MAX due to insurance. and even then, most of that mileage is playing the streets. I wouldnt see any benefit in an od. Im not a power tour guy.




I am running a TKO (Keisler), 440-6(e-brock heads and Huges 535/515 cam), 3.91 cogs, 26" tall rear rubber. I religiously got over 20mpg driving from Chicago to St. Louis to MMW. 24MPG was the high. Made that run three times and was cruising at about 2200rpm at 69-72mph. Just as a reference for the MPG club.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144715
11/11/08 05:40 PM
11/11/08 05:40 PM
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 298
Knoxville, TN
KEISLER Offline
super street
KEISLER  Offline
super street

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 298
Knoxville, TN
Quote:

I'd really like to thank both Jamie and SHaffi for providing input into this thread. That says a lot about both of them and their products they sell. I really do appreciate hearing their opinions as well. Its nice to know they care about the products they sell.
THANK YOU!




Sorry I am late to the game here, and with the exception of Tom Quadrini's sh!tty-as-usual 7 year old comments, I think this is a good discussion.

Only a couple of things to add here:

1. Customer Service - this is our main focus now, and we have VERY FEW complaints. Product is shipped quick now (4-7 days), backorders and other issues very small. We are doing much more volume - including automatics now also.

2. Pricing - a TKO PerfectFit kit runs $3300 (deduct $400 for a standard fit, which will also get the overdrive in the car, but with much more work). The bell modification is No Charge. The sealed release bearing with carrier is $79, clutch disk $69. So the price to do a swap, including brand new high strength computer balanced and painted driveshaft, new crossmember, new speedo cable, new roller pilot bearing, new isolator, new hardware, new pro shifter mechanism, new clutch disk, new releaser bearing is $3448. (And it was $200 less before Tremec's material & energy cost increase October 1.) I don't know how this compares to Passon, because I don't price his stuff, nor expect him to do the same.

So for $3448, there is a lot of value with the Keisler kit. Perhaps lesser value to those that already have a new releaser, new driveshaft, new clutch disk, etc., but still a lot of value.

3. Ratios - the TKO ratios have the smallest step change of the two choices, and this means RPM drop will be the smallest between gear changes.

4. Torque - the TKO 600 is conservatively rated at 600 FT-LB torque. You can easily run 750 FT-LB with no problem whatsoever. During a torque durability test on the dyno at Tremec, the holding fixture broke at 1400 FT-LB, and the transmission had no failure. So how much torque do you need?... John Holmes vs. Dirk Diggler - either way it's overkill.

5. Technology - Keisler kits offer current OEM technology and unparalleled manufacturing capability and metallurgy, along with long-term availability of OE service parts nation-wide. Add to that, perfected accessory products like our bellhousings, hydraulics, dual friction ceramic-metallic/carbon-organic clutch, shifters handles, pedals, and it's an affordable 1-stop shop to make complete swap with unbeatable value. Check out this video interview from SEMA last week here KEISLER at SEMA

We have sold many, many thousands of tranmissions since 2000, and our business remains the #1 Selling Tremec swap kit on the market for good reason. Plus, unlike other johnny-come-lately-wannabe sales guys peddling tremecs, I am a Mopar enthusiast, hands-on restorer and I care about Mopar and many of you know that. I started my business in 1991 restoring dashes for our Mopar muscle cars, then got into manufacturing Chrysler-licensed parts with One More Run, then my own lenses, then into the transmissions. Passon is also a Mopar guy and while we compete, I respect what he does and think he does a good job with the A833.

At the end of the day, it comes down to what fits your budget, your skills, your driving style, etc.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: KEISLER] #144716
11/11/08 05:51 PM
11/11/08 05:51 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
V
VanishPt Offline
master
VanishPt  Offline
master
V

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
nice video

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: KEISLER] #144717
11/11/08 05:57 PM
11/11/08 05:57 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass


4. Torque - the TKO 600 is conservatively rated at 600 FT-LB torque. You can easily run 750 FT-LB with no problem whatsoever. During a torque durability test on the dyno at Tremec, the holding fixture broke at 1400 FT-LB, and the transmission had no failure. So how much torque do you need?... John Holmes vs. Dirk Diggler - either way it's overkill.





Hey Shafi,

I know talking to your guys with one of my current "projects"........they were hesitant in using the TKO 5spd 600/650 behind the combo I want to build.......but I kinda made up my mind to test the Keisler TKO 5spd ...behind a 570 CID RB, running an 8-71 1:1 drive F.I.,......looking at 850-900 HP, max 1000 ft lbs......Oh Yeah! .....so how dose that warranty program go again......should I need it

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144718
11/11/08 06:22 PM
11/11/08 06:22 PM
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 298
Knoxville, TN
KEISLER Offline
super street
KEISLER  Offline
super street

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 298
Knoxville, TN
Hey Mike,

With the new clutch technology we have now, I think you can make it all happen with single disk technology for a totally streetable setup. I did not want to run a twin disk setup due to the inertia of the clutch on the sychros. I didn't want to run a solid hub either. Now we have the solution for that with a ceramic metallic blend that is just fantastic. I am running it in my Dakota R/T with 6-speed.

The other issue is clamp force with the plate, while managing the pedal effort. Again, we are on the cusp of another winner. We are doing the dynamic balance trials tomorrow, then moving forward to vehicle testing. In the meantime, if a heavy pedal is OK, we can use a stage 3+ spec.

The other thing to consider is keeping a spare transmission when racing it with this 1000 FT-LB mega torque. This will improve uptime in case of a breakage on the track. For street, if the tires spin, it is a non-issue - the trans would never see the full torque.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: KEISLER] #144719
11/11/08 06:41 PM
11/11/08 06:41 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Shafi




You know me!...all to well! ........like I told Jeff, I'm looking to build a wheelstander.......so clutch, and the first 2 gears are paramount........going to build a chassis to "hook-it-up" big time.......with gearing in the 4:80-5:30 range........a few "pulls" in the box, then a few passes down the track,......and I want to drive it home!......that's not asking much is it?


and yes I was focused on the single disk.....

4806845-0000a.jpg (74 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: KEISLER] #144720
11/11/08 06:49 PM
11/11/08 06:49 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
V
VanishPt Offline
master
VanishPt  Offline
master
V

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
i have the Spec stage 3 clutch setup. I do not think it is heavy at all.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: VanishPt] #144721
11/11/08 06:55 PM
11/11/08 06:55 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

i have the Spec stage 3 clutch setup. I do not think it is heavy at all.







Well a heavy clutch dosen't bother me Mark,....I had a 3400 lb BorgBeck in my T/A for years!.....are you running a hyd. set up with your Spec clutch?......

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144722
11/11/08 09:24 PM
11/11/08 09:24 PM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
V
VanishPt Offline
master
VanishPt  Offline
master
V

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Richmond Va, KeislerTKO 60...
Yes I do. I installed my unit in March 06. I think I have the first "Perfect Shift 3" to come off the line. Unit works great > I have about 13k miles on it so far.

The only thing that would make this better is if Chrysler had put that Torsion bar crossmember about an inch higher!

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: VanishPt] #144723
11/12/08 01:52 AM
11/12/08 01:52 AM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

Yes I do. I installed my unit in March 06. I think I have the first "Perfect Shift 3" to come off the line. Unit works great > I have about 13k miles on it so far.

The only thing that would make this better is if Chrysler had put that Torsion bar crossmember about an inch higher!







Good to hear Mark!......Thanks,..I'll assume it's in an E body by your "handle"....VanishPt!

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144724
11/12/08 12:46 PM
11/12/08 12:46 PM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
Gene,
Well, I do stand corrected. So, lets compare the aluminum unit to yours. We still weigh 9 less pounds with shifter and linkage. Seriously though, 9 pounds really never concerned me when building a car. Apparently to some it matters and that is fine.
DAYCLONA, I do love the "Whaaaambulance" comment. That had me laughing out loud. I never heard that before.

As for comparing quotes. Yes, when you are talking about ceratin vehicles switching and automatic car over, I am sure that we can be more money. However, be fair in bringing to light that we are dealing with CORRECT factory components wheras you guys are dealing strictly aftermarket. So, the thought process goes hand in hand with the theme of the car. If you don't mind having the aftermarket stuff, the cost can be lower. Its kind of like for example a valve cover breather. You can buy the "Moroso" slip on one for 20.00 and it will work. You might have to modify the valve covver a bit to get it on there, but it can be done. However, if you want the car CORRECT, get ready to pay the $100.00 for the CORRECT original breather. Unfortunately original stuff commands a higher cost. NOW, I am not saying that the Moroso breather is necessarily junk. I am just saying that it isn't truly CORRECT for the application and the reality of possible mdification can justify a cheaper cost in certain instances.
I can recall a situation well where a gentleman called me regarding a set of pedals that he bought from you guys and they were made to ONLY accept the hydraulic throwout bearing kit that you offered at the time. It didn't have the small "rivets" on the pedals for such things as the pedal rod and overcenter spring. So, once again, if the customer bought them, they are LOCKED IN to buying the hydraulic kit from you. Maybe this has changed now, but it wasn't like that before.

Compare a stick to stick quote and I think that the tables would be turned. Regardless, if people want a 5 speed, they will be willing to pay whatever it costs. I have seen that first hand. Bottom line, if you don't mind modifying your cars, the Tremec is a viable option. If you do mind modifying it, our unit is the way to go.
I'm not going to sit here and throw rocks back and forth. We are too busy.
Thanks,
Jamie


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144725
11/12/08 01:33 PM
11/12/08 01:33 PM
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Keisler Sales Offline
Keisler Sales  Offline

Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Jamie,

Well based on Pricing it would cost the average guy who is swapping an E body $448 more to go with our kit.

Here is the main benifit.

Performance

comparison

Yours Ours
1st 2.66 2.89
2ND 1.59 1.89
3RD 1.0 1.28
4TH .80 1.0
5TH N\A .64 OR .82(NOT REALLY RECOMMENDED)

The performance of one transmission vs the other is clear.

You have a great solution for the guy who doesn't want to take the chance he may have to modify.

We have many installs with no mods and very minimal on others.

Btw Next time your at Sema just don't walk by stop in and say Hi

Gene


Keisler Engineering www.keislerauto.com
#1 Choice of Overdrive Transmissions with Over 14,000 Sold
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144726
11/14/08 12:43 AM
11/14/08 12:43 AM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
MadMatt Offline
super stock
MadMatt  Offline
super stock

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
Hey Gene,

I've been going contemplating the conversion from 727 to tremec in my '70 Dart for a couple of years now. I think I may have finally gotten up the nerve (and the money), but I'm still troubled by the need to cut the torsion bar x-member. Any chance you could post a worm's eye view of how much cutting is necessary on the A-body? Have there been any changes in the kit (fit-wise) since the days of the Green Brick conversion?

Hoping to be soon.


Some see the glass as half empty, some see the glass as half full. I just drink straight out of the bottle.
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: MadMatt] #144727
11/14/08 09:23 AM
11/14/08 09:23 AM
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Keisler Sales Offline
Keisler Sales  Offline

Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 211
Tennessee
Quote:

Hey Gene,

I've been going contemplating the conversion from 727 to tremec in my '70 Dart for a couple of years now. I think I may have finally gotten up the nerve (and the money), but I'm still troubled by the need to cut the torsion bar x-member. Any chance you could post a worm's eye view of how much cutting is necessary on the A-body? Have there been any changes in the kit (fit-wise) since the days of the Green Brick conversion?

Hoping to be soon.





Hello Matt,

We have made some mods to the trans in the area for the torsion bar crossmember.This has reduced the need in many cars. We still see guys having to notch the torsion bar member but it is small. There is some differences in cars and condition also plays a part in this as well.

I think I just did a little dance around your question.

Unfortunately there is no rhyme or reason for this.

So with a little bit of this you will be able to do alot of this


Keisler Engineering www.keislerauto.com
#1 Choice of Overdrive Transmissions with Over 14,000 Sold
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144728
11/14/08 10:55 AM
11/14/08 10:55 AM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
MadMatt Offline
super stock
MadMatt  Offline
super stock

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
Quote:


We have made some mods to the trans in the area for the torsion bar crossmember.This has reduced the need in many cars. We still see guys having to notch the torsion bar member but it is small. There is some differences in cars and condition also plays a part in this as well.






Gene, I know every car is different but are you saying SOME A-body installs can now be accomplished without notching the x-member? Just wondering, I'm not asking you to predict either way on my particular car.


Some see the glass as half empty, some see the glass as half full. I just drink straight out of the bottle.
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Keisler Sales] #144729
11/14/08 01:36 PM
11/14/08 01:36 PM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
Gene,
Thanks for the invite. I do appreciate it. However, the last time I did that it only got me into a HUGE "discussion" on this board that ended up getting the post locked and started a whole bunch of hard feelings. So, that being said, thank you, but I thought it better to not bother you guys. If I remember, wasn't there a guy there anyway? I didn't want to interrupt you.

Now to some math:

Here is my biggest problem with you guys saying that the ratios in our trans are so wide.

1st to 2nd gear change is 1.07 in our unit. It is 1.00 in yours. Maybe I am out in left field, but I really don't call that tremendously different.

2nd to third gear change is .59 in our unit. It is .61 in your unit. So, you are actually wider there. Again, I am not going to say that you are tremendously wide either. But in fairness, I never claimed that you were.

3rd to 4th is .20 in our unit and .28 in yours. AGAIN, WIDER!!!!!!

Yes, you have a 4th to 5th gear shift. However, when talking ratios, that is not relevant.

In my opinion, the ONLY thing that you guys have over us is a taller OD. Which is fine, however, it seems to me that strength might be compromised by doing this. That is why we didn't make a steeper OD. We were concerned about making the stongest unit we could. Regardless, I have not personally had ANYONE call me complaining that the OD was not enough.

Now, I know the story of the transmission fixture breaking at 1400 lb/ft of torque, but lets be serious, if this were the case, a tremec trans would be virtually IMPOSSIBLE to break. I think that we both know that his isn't the case. I find it wierd that if they can take 1400 lb/ft of torque, then why are they rated at LESS THAN HALF of that number???? I know this, If my unit could take 1400 lb/ft of torque, I sure as heck would not rate it at less than half of its capabilites.

By the same token, I am not saying that one of our units is unbreakable. BUT, I am quite confident that it will take more than 600 lb of torque.


Lets look at another aspect here.

Howabout how steep your 1st gear is?

The final drive ratio in each gear is calculated by multiplying the transmission gear ratio by the rear end ratio. I picked a generic ratio that is a good rear ratio in a car that is a candidate for an overdrive. So, lets do some more math.

Your first gear: 2.89 X 4.10 = 11.84 final drive
Our first gear: 2.66 X 4.10 = 10.90 final drive

That is a .94 difference. The way that you guys talk about how crappy our ratios are, this is a MONUMENTAL difference in gear ratios. No wonder why no one mentions it. So, why isn't anyone pointing this out??????? It seems like a relevant point to me.

Let me also say, there is not personal attack here at all. It is simple math. I am just amazed at how you guys "gloss over" the tremec's shortcomings and point out that our unit has such a horribly wide gear spread. The fact is: IT DOESN'T.




Jamie


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144730
11/14/08 02:44 PM
11/14/08 02:44 PM
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
MadMatt Offline
super stock
MadMatt  Offline
super stock

Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 730
Nampa, ID
Jamie,
As you can see from my posting above, I've been considering the Tremec swap on my '70 Dart for quite awhile, but I've been put off by the cutting necessary. I'd also considered your product, but was concerned about the ratios and the moderate overdrive. After reading your postings and doing a little math your setup is back under consideration. Turns out that even at So. Cal. freeway speeds there is only a difference of about 500 rpm between your setup and the Tremec. So, a couple of questions if you don't mind:

Do you offer a complete kit to facilitate the swap from a 727 to the 833? What kind of price would I be looking at?

What are your thoughts on the pros/cons of OEM mechanical clutch linkage vs. a hydraulic clutch setup?

Thanks!


Some see the glass as half empty, some see the glass as half full. I just drink straight out of the bottle.
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: MadMatt] #144731
11/15/08 01:18 AM
11/15/08 01:18 AM
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
DaytonaTurbo Offline
Too Many Posts
DaytonaTurbo  Offline
Too Many Posts

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 21,318
Manitoba, Canada
Jamie, I don't think anyone's really complaining your gear spreads are too wide on YOUR o/d 833. Now the gears spreads on the 70's mopar 833s were too wide, but oh well.

The only thing I would really like is to have a couple different o/d gearing options available for your o/d 833. Keisler's got a .82 and a .64 available, so you can go either way, but you only have the .8 available. For most of us, that probably makes about a 500rpm difference on the highway. Not huge, and probably enough o/d for most, just looks better on paper to have the .6x gear available. For me, the race is done at the end of the 1:1 gear, so the drop from 3rd into the o/d gear could be huge, it wouldn't bother me because it's just for cruising, not racing.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144732
11/15/08 01:28 AM
11/15/08 01:28 AM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

Gene,
Thanks for the invite. I do appreciate it. However, the last time I did that it only got me into a HUGE "discussion" on this board that ended up getting the post locked and started a whole bunch of hard feelings. So, that being said, thank you, but I thought it better to not bother you guys. If I remember, wasn't there a guy there anyway? I didn't want to interrupt you.

Now to some math:

Here is my biggest problem with you guys saying that the ratios in our trans are so wide.

1st to 2nd gear change is 1.07 in our unit. It is 1.00 in yours. Maybe I am out in left field, but I really don't call that tremendously different.

2nd to third gear change is .59 in our unit. It is .61 in your unit. So, you are actually wider there. Again, I am not going to say that you are tremendously wide either. But in fairness, I never claimed that you were.

3rd to 4th is .20 in our unit and .28 in yours. AGAIN, WIDER!!!!!!

Yes, you have a 4th to 5th gear shift. However, when talking ratios, that is not relevant.

In my opinion, the ONLY thing that you guys have over us is a taller OD. Which is fine, however, it seems to me that strength might be compromised by doing this. That is why we didn't make a steeper OD. We were concerned about making the stongest unit we could. Regardless, I have not personally had ANYONE call me complaining that the OD was not enough.

Now, I know the story of the transmission fixture breaking at 1400 lb/ft of torque, but lets be serious, if this were the case, a tremec trans would be virtually IMPOSSIBLE to break. I think that we both know that his isn't the case. I find it wierd that if they can take 1400 lb/ft of torque, then why are they rated at LESS THAN HALF of that number???? I know this, If my unit could take 1400 lb/ft of torque, I sure as heck would not rate it at less than half of its capabilites.

By the same token, I am not saying that one of our units is unbreakable. BUT, I am quite confident that it will take more than 600 lb of torque.


Lets look at another aspect here.

Howabout how steep your 1st gear is?

The final drive ratio in each gear is calculated by multiplying the transmission gear ratio by the rear end ratio. I picked a generic ratio that is a good rear ratio in a car that is a candidate for an overdrive. So, lets do some more math.

Your first gear: 2.89 X 4.10 = 11.84 final drive
Our first gear: 2.66 X 4.10 = 10.90 final drive

That is a .94 difference. The way that you guys talk about how crappy our ratios are, this is a MONUMENTAL difference in gear ratios. No wonder why no one mentions it. So, why isn't anyone pointing this out??????? It seems like a relevant point to me.

Let me also say, there is not personal attack here at all. It is simple math. I am just amazed at how you guys "gloss over" the tremec's shortcomings and point out that our unit has such a horribly wide gear spread. The fact is: IT DOESN'T.




Jamie









Better watch out guys!....the waaambulance is just around the corner


Seriously, Keisler and Passon make GREAT products and offer GREAT service!.......and it's different strokes for different fokes.....the about gear spreads is rather ......I personally enjoy the Keisler gear ratios, esp the .64 OD.....there's nothing out there to compare with this!....nothing!


Of course Keisler gets my "Kudos" all day!.....but if I was building a totaly stock appearing 4spd car.....I'd go with a Passon box, for the ability of an OD in a stock case.......but again, it comes down to what the owner has in store for his/her car.......a forum pissing match really isn't going to sway a customers finial decision

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144733
11/15/08 03:08 AM
11/15/08 03:08 AM
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,451
So Cal
autoxcuda Offline
Too Many Posts
autoxcuda  Offline
Too Many Posts

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 27,451
So Cal
Quote:

a forum pissing match really isn't going to sway a customers finial decision




From situations I've seen in the past between vendors, this is relatively pretty civil.

But worse than a pissing contest is teasing and namecalling. I don't think either position/party in this thread needs to result to that yet. It just turns off customers from making any decision.

Quote:

Better watch out guys!....the waaambulance is just around the corner



Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: autoxcuda] #144734
11/15/08 12:48 PM
11/15/08 12:48 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
I think both parties agree that each other is delivering a good product to a hobby they both love.
Now that Keisler has addressed some of the issues that have been a constant topic of discussion on this website it now comes down to preference.I don't know if things have changed over at Keisler on the return policy but it used to be a horrible ordeal if you had to return something expensive like a Street-Twin assembly.A customer of mine purchased a street twin from them and was shipped a six bolt version and he ordered an 8 bolt wheel.Long story short they wanted him to buy another one(at over $1000.00) before they would refund the money on the one they shipped wrong.Now to be fair this was almost 8 years ago so they might have changed the return/exchange policy.Having dealt with Jamie I personally know this is not his policy because he puts as much trust in the customer as they put in him.
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144735
11/15/08 05:23 PM
11/15/08 05:23 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Gus....we've all experienced problems with vendors, their human,.... sometimes policies get misinterpeted by employees,.......I've heard stories(on this forum) of customers complaints with Keisler,....I'm not defending or cruzifing them either,....I can only relate my experiences with them over a decade or so dealing with them,....sure I've had the wrong parts shipped to me, but when I've called Keisler, not Shafi, but the same people you, I or Joe blow, would talk to everyday,....they were always quick to ship a part/s out, and for me to return the part/s the same day I received the new parts,....I never had an issuse?......and yes there were times that a major part held up installation, but Keisler was quick to respond, often times overnighting a replacement,.....regardless of what your buying, it's always best to confirm what you have on hand before tearing into a car, if it has deadlines....I'm allways amazed when some guys start a major project, or order stuff days before their intended show, event, race, etc.....then start a crying/pissing tantrum when things go wrong on either end?,....being a vendor myself, you wouldn't believe some peoples expectations or attitudes before you even deal with them!.....or after you deal with them!......I know there's always two sides to a story......and yes there's times when someone is wronged innocently, we've all been there! at one time or another......but me, personally,... I've never known Shafi or any of the guys/gals working at Keisler to be anything other than professional and courteous to me or my customers refered to them, they've all come away with a good experience, and at often times become repeat customers

4815283-0000a.jpg (74 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144736
11/15/08 05:55 PM
11/15/08 05:55 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
Oh yeah I have been to that mountain before and you haven't lived until you've had the "Summit experience" They take your info,take your money,then hand you the wrong part.After that you get to go through the entire process again and hope it's right this time
I will be honest and say I have got the wrong part from Jamie before but he had the correct part on it's way and didn't charge me for the correct part before he received it back.Now that clutch deal happened to my bro-inlaw and he didn't have another $1100.00 in the bank and he thought it was wrong he would have to pay to ship it back and buy another unit for a mistake on Keislers end.So you think that this is a good way to earn customers?
So you would tell your customer"Hey Joe Blow they shipped me the wrong clutch so I will need another grand and an extra $60.00 the ship it back to them and they won't credit your account until they receive it" You have to admit that on some level that is wrong huh ???
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144737
11/15/08 06:49 PM
11/15/08 06:49 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass

So you would tell your customer"Hey Joe Blow they shipped me the wrong clutch so I will need another grand and an extra $60.00 the ship it back to them and they won't credit your account until they receive it" You have to admit that on some level that is wrong huh ???
Gus










Yes Gus that is WRONG, by any standard, any company,......but not knowing the circumstances, and not being there, I can't comment on the event, I have no basis.....like I said earlier all I can do is relate my personal experiences or any my customers, refered to them, and their experiences as relayed back to me,...which to date, I've only recieved one customer "complaint",if you want to call it that? and that was a wrong set of pedals shipped out to a customer,( Keisler insisted they were correct, but they weren't)....my responce was call Keisler, if you have a problem, call me......it was easly rectified,....Keisler sent out another set and had the others returned......I've had wrong parts sent to me before, but never once told, I had to purchase a replacement part or even pay shipping! for their error, they ALLWAYS handeled it professionaly like one would expect...........I'm not relating this to your bro-in-laws ordeal,....but like I said before being a vendor you'd be surprised the number of people who misinterpet a vendors policies, comments.... or ones who try "to get OVER on you" in business dealings......generally if you run a business poorly, you ain't gonna be around too long......I've found Keisler to be very professional in any of my dealings with them, like I would expect them to be, even when a mistake was on my behalf.......(a problem, which some customers,regardless of whom they are dealing with, hate to emit to!)

4815503-0000a.jpg (40 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144738
11/16/08 10:01 AM
11/16/08 10:01 AM
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild
T
ThermoQuad Offline
top fuel
ThermoQuad  Offline
top fuel
T

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,465
Answering the call of the wild
Why don't the snake charmers come out with a customer service policy of satisfaction guaranteed or your money back?? It is supposed to be a perfect fit product so why not?? The truth is the product is not a perfect fit and they are snakes. Snakes slither last I checked...

For over 6 yrs now we have talked constantly about the lack of customer service and fitment problems, along with no reasonable return policy whatsoever. Threads have been locked, people have gone to swap meets and confronted the snake charmers Nothing has changed except for some paid promotion from some blind customers.


Overheard at a swap meat at the snake charmer school swap spot...

They sent him the wrong flywheel(he has a cast crank).

The master cyl for hydraulic clutch was bad.

The trans was jambed and had to be 'broken in' before street driving,

The sheet metal supplied for conversion was a poor attempt

The shifter sucked and buzzed(subsequently fixed by having to replace the shifter mechanism),

The adapter for shifter supplied was poor quality.

The customer berated the head snake to death calling him derogatory names and commenting on his ineptness when it comes to PROPERLY engineering product...

And once thought only unique to unrestored purple AAR cuda's...drumroll please...The driveline angles were way off...


Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144739
11/16/08 10:23 AM
11/16/08 10:23 AM
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
J
JamiePasson Offline
super stock
JamiePasson  Offline
super stock
J

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 869
Sugarloaf, PA. USA
DAYCLONA
I have NOTHING personal against Keisler. PERIOD! However, all joking aside, how is what I posted something that should call the Whaaambulance out? I didn't pick at them, call them names, say that their product was bad or ANYTHING of the sort. I just simply answered their largest claim as to the shorcoming of our trans, which is how wide the gear spread is on ours. I don't think that EVERYONE is saying that. I think that Keisler is saying it. I have personally seen MANY posts in the past about "how our gear spread is so wide and that is why their setup is better." I don't tak this claim personally. Nor do I think that I replied to it in a personal manner. I just simply explained the math problem. Now that it is out, why should I get the Whaaambulance called on me. You OBVIOUSLY had a GREAT experience with Keisler. That is fine. However, to be honest with you, I feel that because I brought some hard facts to the table that really disprove one of their gear spread claims, it seems to have upset you. Thats not really fair. I am glad that you had a good experience with them.

You are right. If someone wants a 5 speed, they are buying a 5 speed no matter what they have to do to the car to fit it period. I am not trying to change their minds. I am just pointing out simple facts as far as ratios. They are not near what they say they are.

Uh oh, I hear a siren as I am typing this. I better go. Hopefully the Whaaaambulance will go by and not stop for me!

Hopefully there are no hard feelings. None were meant to ANYONE.

Jamie.


Passon Performance 309 Turkey Path Sugarloaf, PA 18249 (570) 401 8949 www.passonperformance.com
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: JamiePasson] #144740
11/16/08 01:59 PM
11/16/08 01:59 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Uh oh, I hear a siren as I am typing this. I better go. Hopefully the Whaaaambulance will go by and not stop for me!

Hopefully there are no hard feelings. None were meant to ANYONE.

Jamie.







Same here Jamie, no malice is intended, the Waaambulance is just a jest to break any tension......like I've said earlier the Keisler vs Passon, vs GV, vs Doug Nash, Vs......? will go on forever on this forum and dozens of others.......

If some people are swayed by a forum concensious, so be it,........any comments I make about Keislers products are a direct and honest account of my experiences in dealing with them, just as I'm sure other's comments are, be they negitive or positive........I "favor" or "endorse" Keisler's product because I like the benefits of the application, and any of my/ customers dealings with Keisler have always been positive

I've talked with many people running the Passon gear box, and they are just as passionate (no pun intended) and dedicated to your product as I am to Keisler's product........you have a great product and service to offer as well to the hobby

I too, do find the squabbles between the variables offered between you and Keisler, regardless of who starts the "apples to oranges" comparisions rather trifle.........but it's human nature to argue who's better, who's not........I prefere to offer my experience with a product in question, and offer the pro's and con's of it's implementation........and leave the decision in the end to the customer/ reader

Jamie, as I sure your aware, sometimes it's hard to "read" what's being conveyed in a post, because the reader can't see any emotion, attitude from the poster,.......I have great respect for Passon,......I'm sure you've never heard a bad word from me about your product/ service and never will, although I personaly prefere the Keisler applications,.....you'll see in my past posts, that I also endose the use of your product, should a customer desire that form of application,..... So I apologize if my "manner" or "style" of posting comments, may have offended you, but it's my nature,....I'm just a "masshole"


Mike

4817040-0000a.jpg (72 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144741
11/16/08 03:40 PM
11/16/08 03:40 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

Why don't the snake charmers come out with a customer service policy of satisfaction guaranteed or your money back?? It is supposed to be a perfect fit product so why not?? The truth is the product is not a perfect fit and they are snakes. Snakes slither last I checked...

For over 6 yrs now we have talked constantly about the lack of customer service and fitment problems, along with no reasonable return policy whatsoever. Threads have been locked, people have gone to swap meets and confronted the snake charmers Nothing has changed except for some paid promotion from some blind customers.





Tom,.....I've seen your posts for many years, and while I can't speak on Keisler's behalf, I can only expound my experiences with them,...regarding their Customer service, I've never had any problems getting assistance when needed, wether it be verbal assistance or a part replaced, or exchanged,......I don't know what you mean by a "resasonable" return policy,....perhaps you should elaborate?.......and I'm neither paid nor compensated by Keisler for any "promotion",....and last I checked, my vision was 20/20 both eyes, hindsight not included!


Overheard at a swap meat at the snake charmer school swap spot...

They sent him the wrong flywheel(he has a cast crank).



Tom, I had this same problem with Keisler, Hays, and Summit, and PAW as well......guess what, a simple call, it was returned and replaced

The master cyl for hydraulic clutch was bad.


I've had this problem ONCE with Keisler, in their "defense", they don't make the master, merely offer it,.....but guess what, a phone call later, a replacement was on the way

The trans was jambed and had to be 'broken in' before street driving,


Not too sure what your trying to convey here?....but if your refereing to the intial break in period, yes the Keisler TKO 5 spd is "balky" in 1st and reverse gear for about the first 2-300 miles, after that shifting is no longer a problem,......I take it, you had to crawl before walking also

The sheet metal supplied for conversion was a poor attempt


Yes!,...in full agreement with you Tom, a factory style hump should be supplied with the kit, if not the customer should be made aware of the need for one

The shifter sucked and buzzed(subsequently fixed by having to replace the shifter mechanism),



On some applications, many years ago, the first generation shifter tower would exhibit a "buzzsaw" vibration at certain speeds/ RPM's.....The issuse has been eliminated with the Keisler 3rd generation shift tower, if I recall in some past threads, Richard at Keisler went out of his way to replace any readers/posters on Moparts who had old shift towers with new 3rd generation shifters if they requested for no charge

The adapter for shifter supplied was poor quality.


Yes, some of the early adapters were aluminum, and would not hold up to prolonged use, I've experienced that myself, and conveyed my concerns to Keisler, guess what.....a steel/ improved replacement(s) were issued, no charge

The customer berated the head snake to death calling him derogatory names and commenting on his ineptness when it comes to PROPERLY engineering product...




Well Tom,....I've VOLUNTEERED (meaning no pay or compensation Tom) my time/ effort at manning a quite a few Keisler venues around the east/mid coast shows, Mopar, and multi-make, also displaying my products, equipped with Keislers TKO and plus4 Auto applications,........never once experienced any "distraught" customers,....I'm not saying it didn't happen, but I would think the old saying,...."You can get more with honey, than ".....goes a long way for either one involved, anyone who runs any business has had to deal with an irate customer, regards of who's right or wrong

And once thought only unique to unrestored purple AAR cuda's...drumroll please...The driveline angles were way off...


Well....Tom, if your installing any item into a vehicle, that it wasn't intended for, regardless of wether it's promoted as "bolt in",...."perfect fit", etc. etc.....I myself would be very diligent in making sure that the installation was proper, and if the driveline needed to be "re-phased",....so be it, there's a lot of variables between applications, that can't be addressed, or known about, until the part(s) are in the field,.....regarding driveline angles, I often find, it's the owner who is addimantly against modifing the crossmember, or floor to properly phase a driveline if needed,.....granted most people are ill-equipped for fabrication, they lack the tools/ and/or knowledge,....I've corrected a few ill attempts of some of my customers "home" Keisler installs that were the direct result of installtion errors, or not having a "working" knowledge of a driveline, it's componets, and proper installation,.....they were always quick to blame Keisler, but blind to their own shortcomings





Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: NV69B7RR] #144742
11/16/08 04:52 PM
11/16/08 04:52 PM
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 898
iowa
copchaser Offline
super stock
copchaser  Offline
super stock

Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 898
iowa
I've run all three overdrive tranys, I feel the Passon one is by far the best. Gearvenders is a force to recon with if you have a heavy car that makes unreal power they are the only way to go. Now if you want to collect a bunch of broken ford mustang tranys, by a Keisler. A Keisler is fine behind a gutless small block. As far as service, Jamie is the man, and with Keisler, a stop at your local junkyard should beable to hook you up with parts. So yes I will run a Passon trany again, and I will run gearvenders again, got one in my moterhome.

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: copchaser] #144743
11/16/08 06:59 PM
11/16/08 06:59 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
Quote:

I've run all three overdrive tranys, I feel the Passon one is by far the best. Gearvenders is a force to recon with if you have a heavy car that makes unreal power they are the only way to go. Now if you want to collect a bunch of broken ford mustang tranys, by a Keisler. A Keisler is fine behind a gutless small block. As far as service, Jamie is the man, and with Keisler, a stop at your local junkyard should beable to hook you up with parts. So yes I will run a Passon trany again, and I will run gearvenders again, got one in my moterhome.








Your comment dosen't hold much "water"

4817603-idiot.jpg (63 downloads)
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: ThermoQuad] #144744
11/17/08 09:47 AM
11/17/08 09:47 AM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Quote:

Why don't the snake charmers come out with a customer service policy of satisfaction guaranteed or your money back?? .....




A bad experience 8+ years ago and you're still going on and on ....

The fact is, we do have a no questions asked "Return policy". It is outlined in our warranty and is readily available online. It reads:

"If the purchaser disagrees with any of the terms of this warranty, please return the purchased item to Keisler within three business days of receipt; Keisler will pay return postage. A decision by the purchaser to retain and install the item purchased will be deemed acceptance of the specific terms of this warranty".

It is expected that anyone spending the kind of money required to convert their car to a 5 speed, read the warranty policy BEFORE giving out their hard earned money. Fact is, most don't. That's not our doing. I for one take the time to read warranty policy's on big purchases I make.

It is also a fact that most guys doing the swap don't take the time to go thru the boxes they receive and inventory their items. Most wait until they have scheduled shop time or enlisted the help of friends. They open the boxes Friday night or Saturday, find that something is wrong and then go on a forum and blow up about "they suck or they didn't do this right" blah blah blah. Like DAYCLONA...I never understood that. Why in the world would someone drop 3 grand or more and then push the packages to the side for a month or more without ever opening the boxes? Donald Trump I could understand, the rest of us...... I just don't get it. It is for that very reason, we now include in our paperwork, a sheet telling you to open up the boxes and do a complete inventory and let us know of any discrepancies WITHIN 10 days of receipt. Hell, I have guys calling me now who purchased a kit back in 2004 and are just now getting around to installing the product only to find they are missing something. While I did ask them why they didn't inventory the boxes 4 years ago, I still helped them out and got them what they needed. Try that with Summit and let me know how that worked out for you.

As anyone that has dealt with me knows, we/I do everything I can to accomodate the customer. If we ship something wrong, I send the correct part, along with a return shipping label, to the customer. We do expect to receive said wrong part back within 10 days or phone calls will ensue. If that fails, then we have no choice but to charge for the parts until we receive them back. Even customers living Hawaii can have something returned within 10 days so that is not un reasonable.

Now on the other hand, if the customer provided the wrong information and subsequently was shipped the wrong part(s) because of it, then yes, you will be charged for the correct one IF YOU WANT IT SHIPPED BEFORE WE RECEIVE THE INCORRECT BACK. Other wise, return it to us and as soon as we receive it, we will send out the correct one.
Is that unfair? I don't think so. Try that with Summit.


For 4 1/2 years now all I have read on here is that you don't like Keisler or the product, we get it. Something happened 8+ years ago that you are unhappy with and like the energizer bunny, you just keep going and going and going. Let's face it, nobody working at Keisler right now was here 8 something years ago except Shafi himself. Fact is, I have been here the longest of any of the current employees and I have been here a little over 4 1/2 years now. I was hired in as customer service/tech support and I think my posts on here and my willingness to help out, speaks for itself. Ther are alot of members on here who have dealt directly with me over one situation or another and I can honestly say, none of them were unhappy with my customer service that I know of. I have given out my personal cell phone number MANY times to members of Moparts so they could pick my brain at nights and on weekends. Have you had anyone at Summit do that for you?


Good lordy man.....let it go already.



Richard
Tech Support

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: rj8806] #144745
11/17/08 11:57 AM
11/17/08 11:57 AM
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,912
The Dark Side
Fasbird Offline
master
Fasbird  Offline
master

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 4,912
The Dark Side
Yeah, like others, I've been guilty of doing just what you are saying. Opening up the boxes much later than receiving them. Kind of keeps everything together, without misplacing the loose items. But, that's me. No one ever said I was smart...

I'd prefer to stay out of this particular peeing contest, but one thing I can say, is that the Keisler customer service has been outstanding through all the years in my personal dealings. As an example, I ordered the hydralic clutch assy kit a couple years ago. This kit has been sitting in a box, as I am just now getting the '71 ready to put back together. I was talking to Gene at the Nats and he showed me the latest generation of slave units. After me telling him I still had the old style unused in a box, he even went so far as to offer to trade me out of the older version for the newer version for very little dollar difference. I don't know how more customer friendly you can get than that? Another example was when Keisler upgraded the TKO rear shifter bracket for better strength/fitment. I already had 3 seasons driving on the trans, and all I had to pay for was the shipping to them. They performed the upgrade, then shipped it back to me at no charge.

This is not a paid advertisement, as I am not one of those guys who get's national noteriety for doing high-dollar builds. Just a regular Mopar guy who happens to have put in a 5spd in his car back in '01. I think this was a season or two before Jamie came out with his product. Who know's, maybe I would have gone that route if it was available back then? All I know, is the Keisler product works great for me and the customer service has been equal to the task. Just another opinion for the mix.

Gar

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: Fasbird] #144746
11/17/08 02:40 PM
11/17/08 02:40 PM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Thank you for the vote of confidence.

While I do understand about opening the boxes and then "maybe" losing something, from a business standpoint, I hope you can see where we are coming from. Many times, our computer has invoiced all the items and then I get a call a month later (or 4 years later) saying, hey, I didn't get this part...... It's a heck of a lot easier trying to locate a folder that was filed 2 weeks ago verses trying to to locate a folder that was hard filed (meaning out of the regular flow of the filing system) a month or year or 4 years ago.




Richard

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: rj8806] #144747
11/17/08 07:42 PM
11/17/08 07:42 PM
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
fourgearsavoy Offline
I Live Here
fourgearsavoy  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 10,551
Rittman Ohio
Well while I am a big fan of time on the job (people ask for me by name because I have been working at my job for 20 yrs) I do understand the need to weed out jerks.While I do not know who my Bro-in-law dealt with about 8 years ago he said the sales rep. that he made the deal with him made him feel like an idiot.I had written down exactly what he needed to order and he ordered it word for word with the rep from Keisler.So you are saying that if you make the mistake on your end you will not ship the right part until you get the wrong part back?
When I deal with Passon and I get a wrong part(very rare occasion though)he ships the correct one before he gets the wrong one
Same deal with Calvert Racing(Cal-Tracs)I needed a little shorter bar and they trusted me to ship them the longer bars while the new bars were being shipped to me.
Why don't you guys trust your customers the same way?
Gus


64 Plymouth Savoy
493 Indy EZ's by Nick at Compu-Flow
5-Speed Richmond faceplate Liberty box
Dana 60
Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: fourgearsavoy] #144748
11/18/08 11:15 AM
11/18/08 11:15 AM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Quote:

.....So you are saying that if you make the mistake on your end you will not ship the right part until you get the wrong part back?
....





No, that's not what I said at all. Go back and re-read it. I said that if WE make the mistake, I send the correct part, along with a pre-paid shipping label to retrieve the incorrect one, up front.

If the customer makes a mistake, then we ask that the incorrect part(s) be returned first BEFORE we ship the correct at no charge. If they need the correct one up front, then they need to pay for it and then we will credit them back after we receive back, the incorrect one. At the very least, I have re-sent the correct parts when I was provided a tracking number for the incorrect parts.

As I said in my other response, I don't know who your brother dealt with 8+ years ago but there is no one here now that was here 8+ years ago. I also apologized for his troubles on more than one occassion, yet everytime he posts in a thread involving Keisler, it's the same old rhetoric.
I cannot speak as to what happened here 8+ years ago. I can speak as to what happens here now and within the past 4 1/2 years since I have been here in customer service and tech support. Those who have had issues since I have been here, should be able to say that they were treated fairly by me.


Everytime a thread starts that has the name "Keisler" in it, it always revolves back to the same old crap. This thread was started by someone who was looking for benefits and negatives about going with either a Keisler kit or a Passon kit. Now look where it has gone to.
It has been posted earlier in this thread that we have the utmost respect for Jamie Passon and his product and that it has it's place in the Mopar community. For those who are looking for a deeper overdrive, then we are a viable option.



Richard
Tech Support

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: rj8806] #144749
11/18/08 01:42 PM
11/18/08 01:42 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass


Everytime a thread starts that has the name "Keisler" in it, it always revolves back to the same old crap. This thread was started by someone who was looking for benefits and negatives about going with either a Keisler kit or a Passon kit. Now look where it has gone to.




Richard
Tech Support








Richard......you know that this will continue until those who don't run Keisler products tire from dragging the same "tale of woe" from post to post,.......plus the "mob mentality" syndrome takes effect........but generaly I find that people, seriously interested in running a Keisler set-up often PM me to pick my brain for my opinion,.....although I think I express it here enough ......and tips to avoid any mistakes or pitfalls that a first time installer may encounter,.........and I find perhaps half of them later contact me, to update me on their Keisler purchase,.....the other half are generally banking their money for a future purchase...........so while "Keisler" threads seem to always turn into a bashing thread, seemingly brought on by the "same o' same o'" group.........I don't really think it has any impact on someone's future purchase.......there will be those thar say it does?.......kinda like the same people who complain in Year One threads,.....but I sure they still purchase from YO.....regardless



Richard, hopefully, you may have "addressed" a few issuses in this "round"........and maybe some of those "issuse" will be out for the count?

We'll see next round

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? [Re: DAYCLONA] #144750
11/18/08 01:56 PM
11/18/08 01:56 PM

A
Anonymous
Unregistered
Anonymous
Unregistered
A



and this is why it is so important for a company to have a good product that works as advertised. and if a bad one slips happens to slip out the door, the company needs to provide good customer service everytime, every sale, all the time, because people dont forget. and they dont want others to forget.

i know that if ive read something negative about a company, it sends me in the other direction- unless its just from one guy who 'cant ever be satisfied no matter how much the company tried'

but when you see a post about a rude, unforgiving, uncompromising, didnt work as advertised or couldnt get any satisfaction type of company, thats gonna stick with you for a LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG time. its not like the olden days when you could tell a customer to get lost and feel confident that he can only tell a few people about the lousy service they got. but nowadays, theres the internet and one bad post travels very far for a long time

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144751
11/18/08 02:56 PM
11/18/08 02:56 PM
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
rj8806 Offline
enthusiast
rj8806  Offline
enthusiast

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 227
Tennessee
Quote:

and this is why it is so important for a company to have a good product that works as advertised. and if a bad one slips happens to slip out the door, the company needs to provide good customer service everytime, every sale, all the time, ......





And as DAYCLONA and others have said....our product does work as advertised just as Passon tranny's works as advertised. This thread was initially about comparing a TKO to an overdriven A833. Somewhere along the line, it took a left turn.

Comparing a bad experience that someone had 7 or 8 years ago to a company today is not accurate. Businesses, if they are any good, evolve with time and continue to grow. Keisler has evolved 10 fold from it's original beginnings 17+ years ago. Hell, I have seen it change dramatically in the 4 1/2 years I've been here. My point was a person(s) who feels like they got dealt a bad hand almost a decade ago cannot accurately say or assume that the company is still the same now as it was back then.


Richard

Re: Keisler 5spd or Passon 4spd O/D opinions? #144752
11/18/08 07:43 PM
11/18/08 07:43 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass
DAYCLONA Offline
I Live Here
DAYCLONA  Offline
I Live Here

Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 18,157
Mass


but when you see a post about a rude, unforgiving, uncompromising, didnt work as advertised or couldnt get any satisfaction type of company, thats gonna stick with you for a LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG time










Dan.......dosen't matter if we're talking Keisler, Summit. Year One, etc, etc,..........and I'm not making excuses for anyone here,.....but there are people, that no matter what you do for them, are never happy, never satistfied,......even if you've gone out of your way to solve their problem, and overcompensate their, grief, loss, labor, etc, etc,......their just never happy, you'll see it in any facet of life



Then there's another side of the coin,.....thats the one, where you have a "Mr Know-it-all"........who can't see his own short comings, but who knows it all!........so when he purchases a Keisler, or anything else that he's not quite familiar with, or has absolutly no knowledge what-so-ever, but fools himself into thinking nothings over his head, botches the install, can't get it to work properly, has various problems, all steming from his ineptness,.......attempts to contact the manfacturer, then starts a tirade of verbal assults about what a piece of junk he's got, want's his money back, etc, etc.......in which case the mfg. tries to aleviate the malcontents anger, and fustration, and offeres advice, asks questions,.....seeing that it's done over the phone or internet,......mechanical repairs aren't really easy to do!........so what happens, is usaully the results that we see right here, not just in a Keisler tread, but any thread for that matter........

I said it a few times here, when some people are having not just install problems with Keislers, but just about anything,.........a lot of times, if your unfamilar with something, instructions included or not,or past experience with something "simular" ......installation error, or operator error is usally at fault,......let me give you a perfect example,......an individual working with me, (one of those, knows-it-alls) installed a brand new Keisler, or attempted too?, when I got to the shop, he was having a hard time getting it into the bellhousing, I stopped him and questioned his "prep" of the tranny, and being a "know-it-all" said, "I've done this before!".....after argueing about "proper" installation,....."MR.know-it'all" had his way,.....long story short,....He completely sheared off the input shaft in less than 25 miles! .........after towing the vehicle back to the shop, I disasembled the Keisler 5 spd,....all this time, he's ranting what a piece of junk! .......guess what? "MR know-it-all" forgot to install the front bearing retainer BEARING! when he installed the hyd. throw-out assy,....which he was unfamiliar with!.....but he "knows everything".....he's "done this before"......I wanted to diassemble it before it went into the car, but he siad no!.....he knew what he was doing!...........and them he wanted to try and hide the fact, what he had done,....sent the tranny back to Keisler, playing "dum"......hoping they wouldn't notice? .......I told him to "fess up"


The boys at Keisler weren't buying it,.....in the end he fessed up to his ineptness,.......and Keisler, being GRACIOUS, as they ALWAYS ARE!....repaired it for free, charging nothing but shipping,........had I been dealing with this individual, I would have said you own it pal!.....I'll fix it!, but your paying!......So tell me, dose that sound like a company run by "snakes" as some would say?........I've seen and heard of many other instances, where Keisler has gone above and beyond their "duty" to make a customer happy..........


I could also tell you about a couple of other individual's installs, that were the direct result of "IE" or "installation error"....

Like I've said time and time again, I personally never had a Keisler install, my own, or one that I've done for customers, that presented a problem,....like I hear on this forum, I've never incounted any proplem with Keisler's service, before, during, and after a purchase!........believe me, if I had, I be jumping on the pigpile too!.......I don't get paid to use Keisler products, or "endose" them as some have insinuated, I pay for them just like the next guy!......just that when I'm "happy" with a product or service, I'll "endose" it!, and that's one of the problems here,....people are quick to cut down, but not quick to praise,
someone, or a company, or service, etc, etc

OK.....time for me to go back in my box!

4822313-0609day5.jpg (123 downloads)
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5






Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.1